Monopolies do not stop at 49 percent - Rosneft Deal Jeopardizes Georgia’s Strategic Energy Transit Corridor
05 February, 2015
Monopolies do not stop at 49 percent - Rosneft Deal Jeopardizes Georgia’s Strategic Energy Transit Corridor
When it comes to some topics in Georgian politics, things are eerily silent. Recently 49 percent of Georgia’s Petrocas oil terminal in Poti – one of the few in the entire country – was sold directly to Russia’s largest oil company. And yet the Georgian government has hardly reacted to the Rosneft deal. Even as David Iakobashvili, who made a ton of cash off the deal, gloated at the World Economic Forum in Davos, no one complained. Strangest of all, is that even the most boisterous anti-Russian UNM members have been almost silent about the deal. Sure, Petrocas has a murky past and may have been owned by members of that same party, but even they weren’t selling it to Russia.


The irony is that those sanctions Georgia is now helping Russia circumvent were intended to protect countries like Ukraine and Georgia from Russian occupation and aggression.

If the reason for the Georgian leadership’s silence is some capitulated assumption that they cannot stop such deals from happening in the future, then the entire Georgian government is misinformed. As Dietrich Muller, a co-founder of Georgian Investment Group+, told Georgian Journal’s financial analyst Nino Patsuria several weeks ago: “This private deal reveals weakness in the Georgian government. The state must [and can] have a law that obliges private companies to comply with the government when they plan to divest their stakes in entities of national strategic importance. All developed states do this, but Georgia does not. It is a disgrace when the strategic partners of Georgia impose economic sanctions on the state that is an enemy of Georgia, and then the Georgian government allows a Russian state-owned company into Georgia [to evade those very sanctions].”geotv.ge
If the strategic relevance of the South Caucasian transit corridor is being put at stake, and make no mistake, it is, then why isn’t Parliament acting? Why are Parliamentarians more concerned about a few Chinese and Indian farmers buying small plots of farmland than the foundations of Georgia’s strategic energy corridor being sold to a company owned and run by the same country which continues to occupy it?
Why isn’t the Parliament rushing to push through some bipartisan law on protective legislation for national strategic assets? Or are we missing something? Is something else going on?
Whatever the case, here’s how this looks from Washington: the Georgian government – not just Georgian Dream, but all parties, – in
You must have Flash Player installed in order to see this player.
exchange for a small amount of Russian investment, are allowing Russia to avoid Western sanctions by bringing fuel directly through Georgia in a move that will permanently result in Georgia’s national strategic detriment. Meanwhile, the Georgian government is talking about land plots for NATO training centers and making copious political claims about Western integration.
The problem here is that actions speak louder than words. The irony is that those sanctions Georgia is now helping Russia circumvent were intended to protect countries like Ukraine and Georgia from Russian occupation and aggression. What’s even more unfortunate is that those “strategic partners” of Georgia, like Germany and the Baltic states for instance, are paying a very heavy financial and political price to push those sanctions through.

The Military Element

The oil behemoth has its eye on the entire trans-Caucasus region, not just Georgia.

Perhaps even more alarming is the possibility for Russia to use the presence of its state-owned oil company as a reason to invade Georgia or to carry out military exercises off the coast of Poti – justified by the Kremlin’s oft-used “protection of national assets” argument. As history shows, simply having such Russian State assets in Georgia may give the Kremlin cause to attempt to act as a “moderator” in any possible future conflict – to “ensure peace and stability in the region.”
Furthermore in a long-term way, this move could harm Georgia’s relations with Azerbaijan, Turkey and other partners integral to Georgia remaining a strategic corridor.

So how did this happen?

The lack of liquidity makes this an extremely strange time for an acquisition, and it signals this move is more politically driven than economically.

geotv.geAt the end of December, Rosneft bought a 49 percent stake in Petrocas Energy International, a Georgian chain of filling stations. Petrocas trades oil in the Caspian and Black Seas and operates the largest retail petroleum station chain in Georgia with 140 Gulf branded stations.
Thing is, the decision does not make immediate business sense for Rosneft. The Russian state-owned company does not stand to gain much by expanding its petroleum distribution in Georgia, and it is using up valuable cash reserves to make the purchase. With oil down 48 percent and the ruble down 46 percent, Rosneft is struggling to pay its debts and is running low on cash. It has $60 billion in debt, $20 billion of which will be due in 2015. Without access to cheap Western funding, Rosneft will have a hard time paying its dues. Furthermore, the company has shelved and scrapped several offshore investment projects. The lack of liquidity makes this an extremely strange time for an acquisition, and it signals this move is more politically driven than economically. And that’s the catch.
Rosneft issued a statement on December 29, claiming, “Through the joint venture, Rosneft will considerably expand its presence in the region, amplify its geographic reach, and further diversify its supply routes options.” The oil behemoth has its eye on the entire trans-Caucasus region, not just Georgia. Armenia, specifically, depends heavily on imports through Georgia’s Poti terminal, which is owned by Petrocas. Georgia is uniquely positioned to be a significant and influential energy corridor, not just a consumer.

Georgian Gain


With only 49 percent, Rosneft does not have a controlling interest. Georgian businessman David Iakobashvili owns the controlling share of Petrocas. At the World Economic Forum in Davos this week, Iakobashvili said, “That joint venture will be managed by Georgian management is an unprecedented fact in the recent business history of Georgia.” He asserts that Rosneft will have no control, though only one percent stands between it and a controlling interest.
Iakobashvili continued his defense, stating, that “approximately a $200 million investment is planned to be made into the economy of Georgia, which will provide up to 1,000 new jobs.” Apparently, Rosneft will help rebuild the port providing foreign investment and creating Georgian jobs. It all seems too good to be true. If only we could forget about history.

Complicated by Crisis

To put it lightly (and mildly sarcastically), the deal is untimely. Georgia’s allies have imposed direct economic sanctions on Rosneft, cutting off access to funding and western trade. The sanctions were imposed in response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Georgia can sympathize with Ukraine and its territorial integrity, and should support the sanctions. How the Georgian government reacts (or non-reacts) will shape the seriousness of Georgia’s stance on Russian encroachment in any country. It may also affect the willingness of Western allies to offer aid. Sanctions come at a cost, a sacrifice for the sake of moral principle. War is also a cost, one that Georgia knows all too well. War is more costly.

geotv.geTake Your Time

Economists estimate if oil remains below $60 per barrel, Russia has a year before it burns through all of its foreign currency reserves. The Georgian government should take its time reflecting on history before appeasing Russian businessmen in their acquisition of strategic ports.

Russia’s oil production hit a post-Soviet record high last year. This is the only way an oil-dependent economy can make more money – sell more oil. The stubborn strategy may work for the short term, but important Siberian fields are depleting quickly. As revenues have declined with the price of crude oil Rosneft is desperately trying to make up for lost revenues by selling more barrels.
Russian state-owned monopolies are good at one thing – expanding their monopolies. They infiltrate, expand, and dominate markets with subversive subsidies, pernicious pipelines, and potential beachhead ports. Monopolies overwhelm the market, force out competition, and create long-term gaps between supply and demand that consumers ultimately pay for.
Russia is too late in the game to start diversifying, and its other business ventures like the South Stream Pipeline are beginning to fall through. Economists estimate if oil remains below $60 per barrel, Russia has a year before it burns through all of its foreign currency reserves. The Georgian government should take its time reflecting on history before appeasing Russian businessmen in their acquisition of strategic ports. Monopolies do not stop at 49 percent.

Author: Thomas Kapp
Other Stories
 “Lampi” – Handmade lamps by young Georgian designers
A group of Georgian designers has founded a new company called Lampi, for producing handmade lamps of wood, metal and glass.
Solar panels bring electricity to Georgia’s mountainous Tusheti region
In Tusheti you won’t see overhead electric lines anywhere and it has always been that way.
Georgian Products Enter Arab Market
Georgian company Sairme Mineral Waters announced its entrance to the 32 million-consumer Saudi Arabian market
The first Media Forum to take place in Georgia, organized by Business Georgia and Bank of Georgia
Media company Business Georgia and Bank of Georgia, the leading Georgian bank are going to hold the first large-scale business forum “Media Industry 2016”
NATO Military forces serving in Afghanistan might be supplied with Georgian mineral water
Mineral waters producing company “Tskali Margebeli,” whose most famous brands are Nabeghlavi and Bakhmaro, plans to
 Gogowine - 27-year-old Georgian PR manager becomes successful winemaker
Keti Berishvili is a 27-year-old Georgian winemaker. Her family has been doing this business for the last several years
Georgian dried fruit company prepares to enter EU market
‘Kareli Fruit’ is preparing to enter the European Union market.
The Secret of the project Green Diamond’s Success
50% of the apartments have been sold in 1 week
What Rustavi will look like after renovation
Renovation works are underway in Rustavi, 25 kilometers southeast of Tbilisi.
Four double-deck railcars to operate in Georgia from July
Stadler KISS double-deck railcars will start servicing passengers on Georgian railways from Tbilisi to Black Sea resort cities from this summer
 Young winemaker from Tusheti to revive forgotten species of Georgian grapes
Shota Lagazidze is a 26-year-old winemaker from Tusheti, a mountainous region of Georgia.
TGM Consultants Expands its Caucasus Presence with New Leasing Appointment at Armenia’s Rossia Mall
Dubai, United Arab Emirates - May, 2016: The owners of the recently launched Rossia Mall in Armenia have appointed TGM Consultants
Tourist Complex to Be Built in Georgia’s Racha Region
Tbilisi – United Arab Emirates-based company Israel Ahmadov Investment announced that it will build a USD 500 million tourist complex near Shaori Lake
 Georgia ranked 29th among 50 cheapest countries to live by US website
Georgia has been ranked  29th among 50 cheapest countries to live by an American website TIME.com
Georgian wine company wins gold trophy in France
Another pleasant news for Georgia and Georgian wine-makers. The company “Winery Khareba” had another success at the prestigious wine contest-“Citadelles du Vin”
Delicious diversities of dried fruit produced in Georgia
Dried fruit producing is becoming more and more popular in Georgia as numerous factories have appeared throughout the country.
“Sweetest news” from EU Ambassador: Georgian honey to be exported to EU market
"Since signing a free trade agreement, this is Georgia’s first chance to export Georgian honey to the EU market without any additional fees,"
Spanish Jamon to Go Georgian?
A delegation of Deraza Iberico Company visited Georgia to study varieties of Georgian pig
Georgian philologist runs kiwi plantations in Samegrelo
A philologist by profession, she set up kiwi plantations in Samegrelo’s village of Zemo Etseri in 2011 and USD 200 000 investment has now become ten times more.
Frontera Announces Work Upgrade for Gas Complex in E. Georgia
TBILISI - Frontera Resources Corporation, a US-based independent oil and gas company, announced an operations update
Double-decker trains to start functioning in Georgia soon
New double-decker trains equipped according to European standards will be available for the passengers in Georgia
Google to finance Georgian students’ startup
A team from the Georgian Free University has become the winner of Tango Project App Incubator competition held by Google.
Georgian teenagers start producing perfume
Four 10th grade students from Tbilisi’s 51st public school have produced a perfume under the brand called Magical Potion.
First online wine-shop starts functioning in Georgia
An online wine-shop called “Bino” has emerged at the Georgian market recently.
Traditional Adjarian Baklava to appear in Tbilisi soon
Soon anyone will be able to buy and sample delicious delight Adjarian Baklava prepared according to old technology.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.3450
EUR
1
EUR
2.5816
GBP
1
GBP
3.0788
RUB
100
RUB
3.5517
Other Stories
DUSHETI, Georgia – The Georgian government and the World Bank will allocate USD 5.6 million (12 million GEL) to fund
A new Georgian clothing brand named Person has emerged in Georgian market.
Georgia is in the midst of an economic maelstrom, Euronews reports.
Situation at Georgia’s mineral water market is interesting: over the last year, the volume of export has grown by 56 percent. According to “GeoStat”, over $114 million worth of mineral water was sold
Some of Georgia’s commercial banks are already buying at 2 GEL per $1. Their webpages are publishing information regarding national currency’s exchange rate in real-time mode.
Georgia's central bank governor Giorgi Kadagidze says Ukraine is in the same bind as Georgia was in when Russia banned its neighbor’s exports in 2006
Food and drinks at the territory of “Kazantip Republic” became cheaper. Some bars and food providers reduced their prices by 20% to 50%. For example, khinkali that cost 2 GEL
On the 20th of August, at 9 in the evening, “Kazantip” festival was declared officially open, with both multitudes of foreign guests and local denizens attending.
From now on, Georgian national currency, the Lari, will have its own symbol. Georgia’s National Bank declared a contest to select the symbol in December of 2013.
Georgian auto business is under the threat of collapse. There’s an unusual lack of people at Rustavi Automarket, yet despite the forced reduction of prices recently, many cars