Motherland Security
17 November, 2011
Motherland Security

History of Georgia, as the past of many other smaller or bigger nations around the world is marked with ceaseless struggle for liberty and independence. Even the United States of America, as big and powerful as it is today, had in its own time shed huge amount of tears and blood to acquire the independence and to enjoy the liberty it has heroically fought for throughout centuries. 

In America, the notions of liberty, rights and equality were elevated to the rank of the most precious national values. Those values have always superseded the necessity of physical safety or economic security. But the world is changing fast, and certain bothering questions are popping up inadvertently: What if entertaining personal freedoms and administering universal liberty of an individual threaten national safety and curb the citizens’ security in the country? What if society feels and behaves so freely that its protection from wickedness becomes practically impossible for the state? What if some day democracy is rendered powerless – due to excessive freedom – to provide for a peaceful and qualitative life? Shall we in this case be faced with an option like – freedom or safety? And if we actually are, what are we going to do? Shall we opt for freedom or for safety? If we believe Benjamin Franklin, one of the Founding Fathers of America, preference should be given to freedom –‘Those who give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.’ These are the words which were written in stone up until now. Should we faithfully continue believing in the quarter-of-a-millennium wisdom, a crystal-clear Western political and philosophical value? I doubt it – let the soul of the great American forgive my temerity to contradict the genius. Ideally, we need to enjoy all those values fully and simultaneously – liberty, safety, rights, equality, consent, democracy, sense of eternal security, defeat of the evil and celebration of the good. If this is possible of course without any substantiated misgivings about our current life, fraught with scary occurrences and our future, loaded with raw sense of uncertainty. Personally, I prefer for my beloved Georgia all-rounded safety – economic, territorial, political, social, psychological, medical and ideological – even if the loss of individual freedoms become inevitable when the situation in the country is dictating so. If life is at stake and measures are to be taken for survival

purposes, I would easily give up on personal liberty and broad democracy. The issue is being just as acute and incisive in the United States. What do we need more – liberty or safety when push comes to shove, when having both is no longer possible? I am not trying to justify any restriction of human rights. I know exactly what they mean. I am just giving a regular heads-up in case we are compelled to make the difficult choice. There is nothing wrong with getting ready for proper handling of a problem if the problem occurs, is there? And a problem might occur anytime!

Other Stories
'Make America Great Again'
The title of this editorial is copied from a presidential campaign slogan – behold, somebody wants to make America great all over again.
“Georgia will be better off with Trump in the White House than Obama”
Bill Thomas is an author and journalist in Washington who has written about politics for more than 20 years.
Electoral Preferences
Electoral Preferences
Call them as you wish but ask of them as much as, for example, the American people are asking of senators and congressman of their choice!
Why so critical?
Why so critical?
Why am I so critical towards my native Georgia, its habits and inclinations, its people and government, its means and ways, its behavior
Into & Beyond Politics
Into & Beyond Politics
It was Georgia’s good luck that several years ago we won the title of the host country of the 13th Summer European Youth Olympic
Off you go, Satan!
Off you go, Satan!
I am not a believer. Neither am I a pure atheist. Both of these stances are extremely hard to maintain. This is why I have sheltered
Double Schooling
Double Schooling
This country has more problems than it is enough for one nation. Sometimes it feels like we are seriously sick and need major professional
Promises to keep...
Promises to keep...
There is so much talk in town about the promises that were not kept... Promise has a momentous psychological effect on our social
Globalized Governance
Just have a look at our modern world – it is no longer the way it was a while ago. All seems to be global in the world that we habitually qualify
Georgia’s Young Volunteers
Several years ago, I wrote an editorial about volunteerism in Georgia, and I am ready to admit that I had written it in rather pessimistic
Tbilisi Big-Band & its Founder
There are some little things in our lovely versatile capital city that make us look and sound absolutely Western. The famous Tbilisi Big-Band
Floods happen, but ...
Georgia is not the only victim of floods and other natural disasters. We are just one of them! Too bad that it has happened to us
Building from top to bottom
Natural disasters have happened before, they are happening now and will happen in the future too. And not only in Georgia, as a
Dr. Alexander Rondeli
We sincerely pain that he is no longer with us, remembering him as Alec Rondeli – the name which became widely known
Equal are the whelps of lion ...
‘The Man in the Panther’s Skin’ by Shota Rustaveli could serve as the most powerful vehicle for Georgia to whisk itself firmly
Russian Political Logic
Russia has its own weird but strongly formulated political logic, and wants the world to follow it. Fair enough, in principle, because
Yes or No to borders
The human love and predilection for having borders and fences has as long a history as the story of civilization itself. This is my territory, and
Crisis, Shmisis...
Economic Crisis! Do­es this sound overly loud? People are talking broadly and extensively about financial crisis in Georgia.
Legalize it or not?
The talk about the oldest profession of the world is just as aged as the trade itself. The subject is always topical here in Georgia too.
Wanted
Wanted
He is wanted! Wanted by the government of the country he once used to be a chief executive of. I am not kidding – he is truly and seriously
President’s Residence
Living and working in the United States, I would often hear people judge the lawyers they want to hire by the car they drive and the attire they are wrapped in.
How about more wisdom?
At this editorial tim­e, I am using some bor­rowed wisdom to squeeze a wise interpretation from what I observe in Georgia. I admit that I cannot grasp the entire picture
Organic what?
Organic what?
I love America but I will never say I know it well. To perceive America, you want to listen in carefully, and meticulously analyze what you hear.
Georgia or Sakartvelo
How many people in the world would know that our darling Georgia has a birth name – Sakartvelo, which is authoritatively legitimized by the main law
Belligerency vs. Continuity
In October of 2012 there came an edgily and extensively awaited-for change of hands in the Georgian government, and it was stridently and smugly qualified
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.3465
EUR
1
EUR
2.6473
GBP
1
GBP
3.6303
RUB
100
RUB
3.5065
GJ Editor's comment
24 July, 2015
This country has more problems than it is enough for one nation. Sometimes it feels like we are seriously sick and need major professional
Other Stories