Independence, impartiality, and the judiciary
13 December, 2012
Independence, impartiality, and the  judiciary
For the first time I can remember in my fifteen years of watching Georgia, judges have publicly disagreed with prosecutors on high profile cases. This is something new and important, and I'm surprised that there is little conversation about it in the media.

In the Soviet Union, the state controlled whatever it wanted and was able to. Things have been more or less the same same since then. Under Shevardnadze, when a state employee asked you for money, you had
to pay them. Otherwise, they would make your life very complicated. It was a very feudal system but one in which the state would win when it felt like it. I have heard people connected with Georgian Dream say that all businesses were controlled by the state under the National Movement. This is not true, but it is true that the state could control any business it wanted to.

The same was true for those picked up by the police: once you were in jail, you were at the mercy of the state. There was practically no chance of a fair trial. The criminal code had extremely strict sentences under the pretense of deterrence and limiting the discretion of judges to prevent corruption and zero tolerance of crime. But in reality the effect was to help prosecutors force people into "plea bargains" as this ransoming came to be known. And it worked. When somebody was brought in, whether they were guilty or not, they would be forced into a hostage payment situation: pay money and serve a shorter sentence. The overwhelming number of individuals who went to prison went not via a fair trial but via a brief, confused, and frightening negotiation with a prosecutor. Those who went to trial lost. Trials and the behavior of judges became so biased that the state passed laws to conceal what happened in court from the population and the international community. And in this way, the state maintained control.

Many judges under Shevardnadze were corrupt, maybe most were, because the whole system was corrupt. When the National Movement came into power, judges were replaced. All of them. And this was not a pretty process. The narrative the National Movement promulgated was that they were all corrupt. And even those who weren't corrupt were replaced too. The priority was to put those with no connections with the Shevardnadze regime in power. When that was achieved, step by step, prosecutors were put in charge.

But so far Georgian Dream has not fired the judges. They have said that they will work with the current judges. Prosecutors have asked that bail not be granted in several cases involving senior officials of the former government and judges have posted bail anyway. That never happened under the previous government. The actual trials have not started yet, and it is not even clear yet if trials will be significantly more transparent than they have been for the last several years, but this is a good start.
One of the symptoms of the state controlling whatever it wants, is that it encourages people to choose sides. If the state has complete control, many will support it out of fear or ambition. And many others will see whoever controls the state as a dictator. Those who are clearly on one side or another tend to be blind to the faults of those they support and to see everybody who is not a supporter of their side as biased against them. But when prosecutors can lose a high profile case in the courts, it begins to interfere with that. People will see that judges can be independent. If judges can be independent, then it is at least hypothetically possible for others to be independent. Judges can set an example for the rest of society in that they can decide things based on the merits of the case and the law. In fact this is how it is supposed to be.

What is interesting is that the new government has chosen not to choose its own people "to be independent" the way the former government did. This is a big risk for, but one that has to be taken at some point. If the new government replaced all the judges, then these judges would surely be as compliant as the current ones were under the former government. People aren't corrupt; they are as honest or corrupt as the system will allow them to be. And if there is political pressure to make biased decisions and little transparency, it is easy to predict how some appointee will act. If everybody can see what is happening, things are open, and there are clear rules about the preservation of independence, then the law will rule and decisions will be impartial.

So in the end institutions are what matter. And if the judiciary becomes transparent and independent, then it will be impartial. Then others will be impartial and individuals will both feel a greater sense of security and at the same time a greater sense of responsibility. Where the judiciary goes is likely to be where Georgia goes, so watch carefully, particularly the trials of those recently arrested and also the fate of the council of justice. The council of justice was responsible for the previous judicial system that the government controlled and one could argue for that reason need to be replaced. But that is a very slippery path.
Other Stories
Everything is possible in Georgia
Lately, I went to West Georgia in order to learn more about the challenges of organic hazelnut farming in the region. My travel experiences give a good impression about how Georgia works and help explain why I feel so comfortable here during my internship at the Georgian Journal.
Welcome to the presidential election circus in Georgia
Before the first round of presidential elections took place, the ruling party “Georgian Dream” was certain of success.
Escape to the country: Visit Lagodekhi
Only a two-and-a-half-hours drive away from Tbilisi lies the small city of Lagodekhi at the foot of the Great Caucasian Mountains.
The two sides of Georgia
On my first few days in Tbilisi, I stumbled across these two contrasting slogans. One is a testimony of open-mindedness and tolerance,
Mentally Ill or Not?
“The brain is wider than the sky.” Emily Dickinson.
Shall We Dance?
“And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who could not hear the music.” Friedrich Nietzsche.
Are We the Same or Just Getting Better?
Georgian-born Mancho Busse has been working in hospitality business for many years by now. Her husband, Robin Busse, works for the State Department of The United States,
Eco-Friendly Habits: How to Clean Your Off-Roading Vehicle Responsibly
Irresponsible waste disposal practices continue to have drastic effects on the environment.
 5 Techniques for Finding Your Inner Creativity
Whether you’re a writer, artist, or even a marketing executive, you’ve probably had days where you felt completely uninspired.
A suitcase full of wine and a heart full of memories
I left Switzerland and arrived in Tbilisi on December 28.
Five Reasons to Visit Georgia in 2017
If you've been searching for a unique place to vacation in 2017, the beautiful country of Georgia holds some hidden treasures.
“All roads lead to Rome” – states one of the most famous medieval proverbs. It’s fascinating to think how much the narrow streets and glorious walls of this eternal city have seen.
It’s Not So Bad, Chaps- Just Look at the Yanks: Ogden on Comparable Politics
Electoral fever is dying down in Georgia as it ramps up in the United States.
 “Moral Inversion” - Pre-election period in Georgia
Georgian pre-election period can be classified as “Moral Inversion”, a notion first put forward by Michael Polanyi.
America’s Trump Card
Like it or not, the name of the 45th American President will most likely be Donald Trump.
Clock is not counting down, it is adding up!
On Saturday for the ceremony in Charleston, instead of wedding gifts, the Managing Editor of Georgian Journal, Will Cathcart
A Protectionist Perspective: Ensuring A Georgian Future
Unlike many of my compatriots, I view my country as a sentient creature, a single organism. The mountains
Back in BSSR
"I remember that when I was a schoolgirl, they told us we have to be ready to give our lives for the motherland.
Thank you, father, for saving me from USSR!
On the 11th of October, the population of Belarus has elected Alexander Lukashenko to serve his fifth term
The EU Getting Squeezed in Georgia
Recent polls have shown that the EU is less and less popular in Georgia. The reason is that they
What is Georgia’s Military For?
There are two possible uses for Georgia’s military. The first would be to fight a war with an external threat or by its existence, to deter
Last weekend I went to a hackathon in San Francisco called Protohack. In the former Soviet Union, people tend to think of hacking
European Migrant Crisis: The good, the bad and the liar
“I call an animal, a species, an individual corrupt, when it loses its instincts, when it prefers what is injurious
Refugees in Georgia
The people of Syria see the Assad regime weakening, and considering who may take over and what they might
David and Goliath: A Realpolitik Rendition
A Conservative Contrarian View on Georgia’s Geopolitical Dilemma
GEL Exchange Rate
Other Stories
GEL Exchange
June 2020
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30