Conscription, National Service and Democracy
17 January, 2013
Conscription, National Service and Democracy
The Minister of Defense has announced that gradually military conscription will be phased out over the next four years. This is a good move, the current system doesn't make any sense. "The Draft" as it is called in America or conscription as it is called everywhere else, has been around for millennia. Wars were fought against neighbors and armies moved on foot. That is no longer always the case and it is very clear that the Georgian army doesn't need
so many young soldiers. This brings up the point, what is conscription for? So originally it was to recruit soldiers, it also gives the government free labor, it can be used as a method of civic integration by mixing units with people of different backgrounds as it was in the Soviet Union or in Israel now, perhaps at least in theory the young recruits could receive some useful training and in general it is often said to be a way to encourage patriotism. But how many of these things are needed, or happen, and should the army be responsible for them all?
In the US, conscription was used during times of war up until WWII. At that point it became permanent until 1973. After that America started what has been called an all volunteer army or professional army but this conceals the reality that it is the the poorest who join the military, and they do it for the money and also sometimes for the job training. But throughout American history there was discomfort with conscription because one way or another, there always seemed to be a way for the rich to get out of serving. During the Civil War in the south slave owners didn't have to serve and you heard the phrase "a rich mans war, a poor man's fight". In the north, people could hire substitutes to fight, or pay not to serve, which lead to the New York Draft Riots of 1863, the largest domestic insurrection in American history. So when there was a draft, the poor were angry that they had to do the fighting. But now there is no draft, there is not that democratic check on going to war. The poorest in America fill all branches of the military, but the the richest Americans often don't have any close friends or relatives serving, but are the ones making the political decision to go to war.


"Democracy does not require perfect equality, but it does require that citizens share a common life. What matters is that people of different backgrounds and social positions encounter one another, and bump up against one another, in the course of ordinary life." This is from a new and very popular book in the US called What Money Can't Buy by a philosophy professor at Harvard, it's subtitle is "The moral limits of markets" Although the military is an important conduit for advancement for many of the least advantaged in America, it is not a force for civic integration and in some countries, this is an important goal. In many societies, Georgia included, there are big divisions: regional, urban/rural, ethnic, language groups, and rich/poor. Some way for individuals from those groups to be put together and work together as a team, if it is done on a national level over several years, could be a powerful force for bringing Georgia together more effectively.


The current system in Georgia doesn't do much of that, mainly because those who can get into university and can afford it, don't participate. And there are many thousands of young men who after they receive their undergraduate degrees, rather than getting some experience working, they continue their education simply to avoid military service. The army in Georgia is largely for those who don't have other options. That prevents its biggest opportunity from being realized. Besides civic integration the army could provide useful training. But armies are there to fight wars, not to train recruits for the job market so very little useful training happens. In reality for most recruits, this year is largely dead time; not very much happens. For most soldiers, there are some exercises, and the rest of the time is spent standing in front of government buildings because there is not the inclination or management to have the soldiers do anything more useful.


One idea could be to de-link the army from the more useful concept of national service. Many countries have some kind of national service. Some individuals don't want to fight, or don't want to support the idea of the military, but others simply have skills that could be used in other ways. It could be possible to have all eighteen year olds enter national service, be put in units that would then undergo some basic team building exercises, some training that would be of use to everybody, and then some go on to the army and others to other forms of service to the homeland. The important thing would be to make the experience valuable and valued by society so that everybody wants to do it. But a good way to start is for everybody rich and poor to have to participate.
Print
Other Stories
The two sides of Georgia
On my first few days in Tbilisi, I stumbled across these two contrasting slogans. One is a testimony of open-mindedness and tolerance,
Mentally Ill or Not?
“The brain is wider than the sky.” Emily Dickinson.
Shall We Dance?
“And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who could not hear the music.” Friedrich Nietzsche.
Are We the Same or Just Getting Better?
Georgian-born Mancho Busse has been working in hospitality business for many years by now. Her husband, Robin Busse, works for the State Department of The United States,
Eco-Friendly Habits: How to Clean Your Off-Roading Vehicle Responsibly
Irresponsible waste disposal practices continue to have drastic effects on the environment.
 5 Techniques for Finding Your Inner Creativity
Whether you’re a writer, artist, or even a marketing executive, you’ve probably had days where you felt completely uninspired.
A suitcase full of wine and a heart full of memories
I left Switzerland and arrived in Tbilisi on December 28.
Five Reasons to Visit Georgia in 2017
If you've been searching for a unique place to vacation in 2017, the beautiful country of Georgia holds some hidden treasures.
PROMISING FUTURE OF COLLABORATION
“All roads lead to Rome” – states one of the most famous medieval proverbs. It’s fascinating to think how much the narrow streets and glorious walls of this eternal city have seen.
It’s Not So Bad, Chaps- Just Look at the Yanks: Ogden on Comparable Politics
Electoral fever is dying down in Georgia as it ramps up in the United States.
 “Moral Inversion” - Pre-election period in Georgia
Georgian pre-election period can be classified as “Moral Inversion”, a notion first put forward by Michael Polanyi.
America’s Trump Card
Like it or not, the name of the 45th American President will most likely be Donald Trump.
Clock is not counting down, it is adding up!
On Saturday for the ceremony in Charleston, instead of wedding gifts, the Managing Editor of Georgian Journal, Will Cathcart
A Protectionist Perspective: Ensuring A Georgian Future
Unlike many of my compatriots, I view my country as a sentient creature, a single organism. The mountains
Back in BSSR
"I remember that when I was a schoolgirl, they told us we have to be ready to give our lives for the motherland.
Thank you, father, for saving me from USSR!
On the 11th of October, the population of Belarus has elected Alexander Lukashenko to serve his fifth term
The EU Getting Squeezed in Georgia
Recent polls have shown that the EU is less and less popular in Georgia. The reason is that they
What is Georgia’s Military For?
There are two possible uses for Georgia’s military. The first would be to fight a war with an external threat or by its existence, to deter
Protohack
Last weekend I went to a hackathon in San Francisco called Protohack. In the former Soviet Union, people tend to think of hacking
European Migrant Crisis: The good, the bad and the liar
“I call an animal, a species, an individual corrupt, when it loses its instincts, when it prefers what is injurious
Refugees in Georgia
The people of Syria see the Assad regime weakening, and considering who may take over and what they might
David and Goliath: A Realpolitik Rendition
A Conservative Contrarian View on Georgia’s Geopolitical Dilemma
The Bleeding of Rustavi 2 - Our New August Surprise
When the powerful have to make something happen that they want few people to notice, they issue the statement late in the afternoon
The Good Neighbor
In 2012, Georgia was promised to witness what ex-Prime Minister Ivanishvili called “a new age.” It would be achieved by “restarting”
Independence, Institutions and Corruption
People talk about Georgia choosing between Russia and the West as if Georgia ended up at a soccer game and, well, since we’re here we may
PHOTO OF THE DAY
Exchange Rates
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
24.09.2018
25.09.2018
USD
1
USD
2.6216
2.6216
EUR
1
EUR
3.0854
3.0854
GBP
1
GBP
3.4584
3.4584
RUB
100
RUB
3.9340
3.9340
Other Stories
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.6216
EUR
1
EUR
3.0854
GBP
1
GBP
3.4584
RUB
100
RUB
3.9340