Do legislative loopholes allow banks to control Georgia’s capital market?
16 October, 2014
Do legislative loopholes allow banks to control Georgia’s capital market?
“After the power shift in 2012, the new government headed by Ivanishvili’s political party Georgian Dream pledged to reform the securities regulation and make it more regulated and in line with the international practice. The bill amending the securities law entered Parliament early in 2013 but has sat there for almost two years. Loladze and Muller believe the reason is the huge lobby of the banks. This past summer Loladze as well as former Director General of GSE asked the
Prime Minister of Georgia, the ministers of finance and economy, Governor of the National Bank, Head of Parliament and Head of Finance and Budget Committee at Parliament to take measures to prevent the banks’ impending monopoly at GSE by restoring cap limits on shares. But this was to no avail. The bill is still is shelved an for uncertain period while GSE is being handed over to banks.”


“Banks always crave monopoly, everywhere in the world, and must not be allowed to manage non-banking companies like stock exchanges. For this reason banks are held back from the management of non-banking assets by laws and regulation in all civilized countries. But Georgian law puts no prohibition on this.”
Loopholes in the regulation of banks and securities allow Georgian commercial banks to establish full control of the Georgian Stock Exchange. Some market players fear that the bank’s reign over the GSE implies the risk that banks will become complete monopolies in the Georgian capital market. This could leave the Georgian economy standing on only one leg and scare investors off. GSE’s new management argues that its staff is well balanced and competent. It plays down the risks of the banks’ dominance at GSE.
GSE has undergone big changes: The new Supervisory Council of GSE elected a new chairperson on October 6th. Giorgi Bachiashvili, Executive Director of the Co-Investment Fund [affiliated with the ex-Prime Minister of Georgia and tycoon Bidzina Ivanishvili] became the new head of the GSE Supervisory Council. A new 12-member council was elected three weeks ago, and banks alone dominate it. Brokerage companies, mostly affiliated with five leading Georgian commercial banks, now hold 58 percent of the GSE and tossed out non-banking GSE members from the management. These non-banking stakeholders holding 42 percent feel discriminated and fear that their interests now will be overlooked. This counters global best practice and risks killing competition within Georgia’s capital markets.
“According to the 39th directive of the EU, to avoid interest clashes between the major stakeholders/owners of the regulated market and the fair functioning/management of this market, minor stakeholders should also have their voice in the management. This directive is completely ignored,” Giorgi Loladze, former Head of the Supervisory Council of GSE, told Georgian Journal.
Non-banking broker companies believe that bank-owned broker companies will carry out the interests of commercial banks that consider GSE as a key competitor and are not interested in making it stronger. Normally stock exchanges are considered as an alternative, more flexible investment tool to banking deposits. Stock exchanges help guarantee transparent pricing in the capital market and insure the inclusion of the population in national economies.
“This change means that banks will become monopolies of the Georgian capital market and our interests will be ignored in future,” Dietrich Muller, a spokesperson for Georgian Investment Group+ [a non-banking brokerage company holding two percent of GSE], worries. “This means that our financial market is missing one leg and the consumer is deprived of an alternative financial source. Brokerage companies are mediators between the client and financial market. But the bank-affiliated brokerage companies will always put their client’s interests behind their own interests. And their interests are tied to the bank’s interests. Once bank-affiliated companies take full control of GSE, it means the Georgian consumer and national economy is left in the claws of banks completely.”
Giorgi Paresishvili, Deputy Chairperson of Supervisory Council of GSE, argues that the council staff is well balanced. He indicates that two non-banking broker companies including ABBEY Assets Management also voted for the new council. Also, among the 12 members of the council, seven are independent persons and only five are representatives of bank-affiliated brokers.
However, the concerned parties believe that the independent council members as well as the said two non-banking brokers that voted for the new council are also affiliated with Bank of Georgia [BOG] through personal connections. BOG holds 100 percent of Galt & Taggart Broker Company that is the biggest stakeholder of GSE with 44 percent.
Paresishvili [who is also connected to BOG by his employment background] believes such allegations cannot be serious.
“It is not plausible to accuse people who worked at certain banks years ago that they are now carrying out the interests of those banks,” he said in an interview with Georgian Journal. He also plays down the assumed risk that the bank-affiliated GSE players will undermine GSE’s position.
“Conversely, stock exchanges do need important financial support and only banks can provide this support in Georgia. Banks are the only financial institution with the skillful personnel and the strong financial resources that are necessary for the development of GSE. The practice shows that banks have always been interested in GSE. Banks founded all the key companies that trade shares at GSE. Let’s take Teliani Valley, Caucasian Energy and Infrastructure for instance that are founded by BOG; Liberty Consumer is set up by Liberty Bank. Construction company M2 and Georgian Leasing Company [both affiliated to BOG] have placed obligations at GSE recently. If banks are not interested in GSE why do they do this?”
Lia Eliava, a financial market analyst, believes that banks may really be interested in GSE development because of they see profit in it. But if the profit fades away the banks may lose this interest and create setbacks for GSE. Therefore she shares the concern that banks’ domination of GSE can be risky for the Georgian economy. She believes this is a problem of bad laws and not bad management in fact.
“GSE is a private company and it is common practice that the owners of the company who hold controlling portions are always dominant in the management,” Eliava said. “But banks always crave monopoly, everywhere in the world, and must not be allowed to manage non-banking companies like stock exchanges. For this reason banks are held back from the management of non-banking assets by laws and regulation in all civilized countries. But Georgian law puts no prohibition on this. Banks can own brokerage companies by 100 percent.”
Actually, Georgian laws regulating the securities market once prohibited a GSE stakeholder from owning more than 10 percent. Banks were allowed to hold no more than 50 percent in total. However, the liberally predisposed former-government lifted the caps during the reforms of 2007-2008. As a result, banks were able to increase their share. Galt & Taggart enhanced its shares to 44 percent ultimately. This allowed Galt & Taggart to prevent the entrance of the international stock exchange Nasdaq-OMX at GSE though all the remaining stakeholders were in support of its entrance. Reforms also allowed over-the-counter trades that removed 95 percent of GSE trades off the hall and utterly shattered GSE position.
After the power shift in 2012, the new government headed by Ivanishvili’s political party Georgian Dream pledged to reform the securities regulation and make it more regulated and in line with the international practice. The bill amending the securities’ law entered Parliament early in 2013 but has sat there for almost two years. Loladze and Muller believe the reason is the huge lobby of the banks. This past summer Loladze as well as former Director General of GSE asked the Prime Minister of Georgia, the ministers of finance and economy, Governor of the National Bank, Head of Parliament and Head of Finance and Budget Committee at Parliament to take measures to prevent the banks’ impending monopoly at GSE by restoring cap limits on shares. But this was to no avail. The bill is still is shelved an for uncertain period while GSE is being handed over to banks.
Eliava believes the bank-affiliated brokers’ entrance into GSE management is illegal because the law on commercial banks activity does not imply clear permission on non-banking assets management.
“But there is a loophole in the law on commercial banks’ activity that gives the opportunity to banks to manage non-bank assets via broker companies. The law must include a clear prohibition of non-profile business management,” she stated.

Print
Other Stories
Business Positive – Successful radio program from Radio Positive
Starting point of radio program Business Positive is to meet interesting people, communicate with them and deliver information that is interesting for the audience.
A factory of electric vehicles to be built in Kutaisi
Prime Minister Mamuka Bakhtadze stated that a factory of electric vehicles will be built in Kutaisi at the presentation of the Aigroup business group.
Qvevri-shaped hotel complex to be built in Telavi
A Qvevri-shaped hotel complex is scheduled to be built in the village of Shalauri in Telavi, Kakheti (east part of Georgia).
Georgian designers presented at Fashion World Tokyo 2019
The products of 11 Georgian designers are showcased at Fashion World Tokyo 2019,
Silknet raises $200 million in Eurobond issue
27 March 2019 - JSC Silknet (“Silknet”), one of Georgia’s leading telecommunications operators, has successfully priced a debut $200 million 5-year 11% senior unsecured bonds issue (the “Notes”).
Pistachio trees will be planted in Georgia
Dozens of hectares of Pistachio are planned to be planted in Georgia this year.
Toyota Safety Sense and Hybrid Technology
Toyota Caucasus, has presented two new models the 5th generation RAV4 and the 12th generation Corolla at Rustavi International Motorpark, several days ago.
Bidzina Ivanishvili “became number one oppressor of businesses in Georgia” - ICC Georgia chairman Fady Asly
Mr. Ivanishvili promised the business community to protect them from harassment and pressure, unfortunately his words died with the sunset of that day
The best brands of Belarus will be exhibited on a large-scale exposition in Tbilisi
"The Belarusians like to come to Georgia to relax near the sea in Batumi as well as to stay in sunny Kakhetia."
Don’t treat business like a hooker! - Georgian businessman Vasil Soprpmadze addresses politicians
Businessman Vasil Sopromadze, founder of the company "Fresco", addresses politicians
RAV4 No Compromise and Corolla Set to Impress – Two New Cars Presented by Toyota
Toyota Caucasus, the company constantly aspiring to greatness, has presented two new models the 5th generation RAV4 and the 12th generation Corolla.
Mamuka Khazaradze quits TBC bank, does not sell the TBC Bank share
I made a decision to leave TBC bank where I spent 27 years of my life
10 Reasons to buy an apartment in the suburbs
There is a tendency for Tbilisi dwellers to move from central parts of the capital to the suburbs.
Georgian citizens are granted the right to work in France
The French Embassy in Georgia made remarks on granting Georgian citizens the right to work in France
The New York Times: Bitcoin declines but Georgia still bet on it
The New York Times has recently published an article about reasons, challenges and causes of generating Bitcoin in the former Soviet country Georgia.
EU to allocate € 13 billion for Eastern Partnership countries, including Georgia
The European Union together with the World Bank plans to allocate investment worth € 13 billion for infrastructure projects in the Eastern Partnership countries.
Anaklia Port and its importance for Georgia
In 2016, Anaklia Development Consortium was authorized to launch the construction of Anaklia Port.
Cryptocurrency mining threatens electrical network in Abkhazia
In the breakaway region of Akbhazia rampant cryptocurrency mining is threatening the shaky electrical network, reports an article of the news portal EuroNet.
Caucasus Wine University to be opened in Gurjaani
In the Kakheti region a new viticulture campus of the Caucasus University is in the process of planning.
Photos describing life of the poorest in Georgia
Fight with poverty should be among top priorities of every government in every country.
Training farmers to rescue the organic hazelnut production in Georgia
Even drizzling rain and unpleasant gusts of wind can’t prevent the farmers from coming and participating in the agricultural training.
Bleak times for organic farmers in Georgia – but there is hope
Organic hazelnut production is a delicate plant in Georgia that has emerged just a couple of years ago. Various pests, among them the Asian stink bug Parosana, trouble hazelnut farmers and menace their livelihood – even before their businesses could really take off.
Hybrid car imports are going through the roof in Georgia
Thanks to their fuel economy, the popularity of hybrid cars is increasing in Georgia, where fuel affordability is low and prices for fuel are unstable.
The New Year offer from MAQRO Construction - Apartments with unbelievable discounts and the parking spaces for FREE!
Location, green yard, spaces for various needs, experience of the construction company and parking space are the main important criteria for potential buyers of apartments.
Interview with the co-founder of Kiwi Vegan Café – the first vegan place in Tbilisi
Behind the Kiwi Vegan Café stands a group of activists who wants to raise Georgian’s awareness for animal rights and welfare.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
20.04.2019
21.04.2019
USD
1
USD
2.6935
2.6935
EUR
1
EUR
3.0291
3.0291
GBP
1
GBP
3.5021
3.5021
RUB
100
RUB
4.2126
4.2126
Other Stories
Recently Toyota rolled out Global Campaign under this slogan that reflects the Olympic and Paralympic Spirit of Encouragement,
A couple from Switzerland combines Swiss tradition and technology with Georgian products. Their cheese is made in the Georgian mountains and sold in local stores and hotels.
It has been more than five years since the residents of Lilo village, near Tbilisi, cannot open their windows.
63 000 GEL was received by the Georgian Agro Export Group which is just a small part of the European Neighbourhood Programme for Agricultural and Rural development.
Georgian entrepreneur Guka Tavberidze, who runs his own business in the UK and does it quite well, has been invited by BBC
The grand opening of 7-star The Biltmore Hotel Tbilisi took place in Georgia’s capital on July 31.
DUSHETI, Georgia – The Georgian government and the World Bank will allocate USD 5.6 million (12 million GEL) to fund
A new Georgian clothing brand named Person has emerged in Georgian market.
Georgia is in the midst of an economic maelstrom, Euronews reports.
Situation at Georgia’s mineral water market is interesting: over the last year, the volume of export has grown by 56 percent. According to “GeoStat”, over $114 million worth of mineral water was sold
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.6935
EUR
1
EUR
3.0291
GBP
1
GBP
3.5021
RUB
100
RUB
4.2126
April 2019
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30