Profit scheme of non-profitable social insurance
10 February, 2011
Profit scheme of non-profitable social insurance

Georgian insurance companies enjoy about 60% of profit margin out of the state-financed health-insurance social programs, Chamber of Control of Georgia found out early this February. And only one-fifth of the target beneficiaries enjoy due insurance service as an aftermath.

Sector pundits say insufficient regulation and low level of awareness plus monopoly positions of insurance companies are the reasons of the lamentable situation in health-care system.

 

Georgian government yields what it has sown. Fears that handover of clinics and the granted insurance right

[over the state-supported consumer] to insurance companies could lead to market monopolization and violation of consumers’ rights came true.
“Alarming”  profit
Chamber of Control of Georgia (CCG) having implemented the preliminary research of the state-supported health-care social programs of 2008-2010 [with total state financing of GEL 284 million] aired  “alarming” conclusion on February 2, 2011 that insurance companies enjoy unbelievable profit averaging to 60% by financing the questioned state-programs, while their profit based  on insurance commercial sector makes about 4%.
According to CCG, out of GEL 284 million ten insurance companies winning the insurance right over the state-supported people spent just 45% on service of beneficiaries [that translates into GEL 114.3 million] and enjoyed 55% [GEL 169.7 million] as a non-taxed profit.
According to the CCG official preliminary research conclusion, the insurance sector is marked by the increased audit risks and deficiencies as following: lack of strict government regulation of the sector, dishonest actions of insurance companies, purposeful limitation of provision of complete medical service, provision of insufficient information to the participants of the program, and alteration and distortion of the database of the program participants.
As a result, only 40% of the state funds allocated for the program have been used and only 21% of the insured [or one in five] could benefit from it.
Giorgi Alasania, Head of Audit Department at CCG, stresses that the profit seems more unrealistic if we take into account that the target beneficiaries [about 900 thousand people totally] are socially vulnerable [including indigent pensioners, unsupervised children, and Involuntarily Displaced Peoples (IDPs) and artists] who need medical service much more freqvently than anybody else.
Companies disagree with the CCG conclusion however explaining that the high profit margin put out by CCG is not a net-profit but it is a non-taxed profit in fact and restrain from making comments till CCG gets through with a final audit result that is upcoming within a month approximately Alasania told Georgian Journal (GJ). Although he fears that the final audit figures very likely would be more scaring than milder.
Giorgi Kvirikadze, top official of GPI Holding insurance company enjoying 57.38% profit margin [by CCG paper], presented financial data of his company in the period of 2007-2010  on February 2, 2011. According to him, the total profit of GPI Holding in 2007-2010 accounted for approximately 6.8% that translates into GEL 6 million roughly. He stressed on trustfulness of the data by underlining that Big Four audit companies do audit of GPI Holding.  Alasania counters that similar Big Four firms experts worked for CCG research and the difference is made because CCG monitored 2008-2010 not 2007-2010, besides insurance companies’ auditors did not separate the state-financed and commercial projects, and CCG research focused on the state-programs alone. 
Success  Story  backgrounds
The 60%- profit-story traces back to 2007 however when under the pretext of discharging state budget from unreasonable expenses government launched reforms of the healthcare system and the state allocations earmarked on socially vulnerable citizens were diverted to the private insurance companies who had to provide target groups by unbelievably cheap [GEL 180 worth] insurance package per person yearly making GEL 15 per month. Meantime the cheapest health-insurance commercial package totaled GEL 25-30 of monthly payment per person and companies suffered of governmental crack-down to undertake the losing venture.
People below poverty level, IDPs, unsupervised children, military and law-enforcer structure employees as well as teachers and about 200 artists were covered by the state budget-based healthcare insurance programs. The number of beneficiaries increased from 750 thousand [in 2008] to 1.25 million in 2010 and the state had to pay GEL 225 million roughly.
Meantime the “volunteer” insurance companies participating in the social-health-insurance project got annoyed and quit. On the other hand the state hospital rehabilitation program failed. Government decided to solve both problems through insurance companies by a win-win deal this time. It divided the state-paid health insurance packages according regional lots and proposed insurance companies to bid for them. To add a lure to the deal government authorized tender participants by granted insurance right thanks to which beneficiaries had no right to change provider insurance companies for 3 years. On the other hand companies were enabled to buy hospital assets in regions and construct new clinics there till the end of 2011 and run them for 7 years. This provision could enable insurance companies to dictate their rules of game to consumer and balance their expenditures at their own discretion by restricting medical service to the clientele. Ten insurance companies came on deal.
Government saved at least GEL 45 million of the budgetary money and insurance companies secured the state-guaranteed premiums for more than million people for three years. However sector pundits have been warning that combining insurance business with the hospital one might lead to obvious interest conflict and monopolization of the market. The single loser in the win-win game seemed consumer since it has no choice right for three years. 
Profit scheme
And the fear came true. The CCG research that monitored only part of the state-financed health-insurance [including indigent people, IDPs, artist, and unsupervised children] is the most conspicuous evidence for it.
According to Giorgi Gigolashvili, Head of Georgian Insurance Institute (GII), a non-governmental watchdog protecting rights of insured people, insurance of the remainder part of social-target programs [specifically teachers] has much more in store.
Insufficient state regulation coupled with the lack of choice and awareness, as well as dishonest approach of some insurance companies led to unreasonable budgetary spending and violation consumers’ rights, Gigolashvili believes.  On the other hand insurance companies try to negotiate clients to get cheaper and riskier medical service instead of expensive riskless aid [recommended by professionals] and withhold with even approved financing for months.
“There is catastrophic situation from the point of view of awareness,” He told GJ. “About 70% of the insurance program beneficiaries do not know that they are insured and some companies take an advantage out of it. Companies are obliged to inform consumers of their rights and all possible service options but they do not, and frequently refuse consumer in provision of due service. And 99% of consumers abandons attempts to get due service after the first refusal. Situation is the most critical in regions as people from regions have to appeal to Tbilisi offices quite often that is extremely discomforting if take into account long queues at clinics and tricks of insurance companies who try to linger financing as much as possible from a month to 6 months, the law enables them so.”
And there is not state structure and strong regulation that can curb tricky policy of insurance business.  The state supported non-governmental Mediation Center together with GII and mediation center of the Association of Georgian Insurance Companies (AGIC) are responsible for protection rights of insured people, but only GII handles with the preventive measures. The Mediation Center handles with actual violations and AGIC center helps non-state insured people. Experts say non-governmental supervision cannot be comprehensive. Central Bank is responsible for financial state and figures of insurance companies but not more.
Ministry of Health-care is in charge with the state-supported insurance program and companies make monthly reports to it but for some reasons it did not notice any wrongdoing so far. Alasania promises to address to researching all the state-financed social programs in near future and dot all i’s and cross all t’s.
He stresses that based on international practice state-supported social-insurance is the most non-profitable business where the average profit margin varies within the 7% while it turned out the most profitable to Georgian companies.
“The unreasonable spending of the state budget is a fact and I never exclude that the final audit papers will be sent to General Prosecutors’ office if any criminal violations are found out,” he told GJ. 

 

Print
Other Stories
Georgian business associations establish Georgian Tourism Industry Alliance
Business associations representing various sector of the hospitality industry in Georgia agreed to establish Georgian Tourism Industry Alliance (GTIA).
IMF approves $200 million for Georgia
The Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund has approved US$200 million financing to Georgia to address the effects of the COVID19 pandemic.
Georgia will be one of the first to open tourist corridors, Economy minister vows
Georgia’s Minister of Economy and Sustainable Development Natia Turnava pledged that Georgia would be one of the first countries to open safe tourist corridors with other countries.
Georgia’s GDP may contract 4%, the worst in the region amid pandemic
International Monetary Fund forecasts a 4% contraction of Georgia’s economy, which very much depends on tourism and money transfers.
Georgian retailers fight for survival as coronavirus pandemic continues
Pandemic has affected everyone worldwide, but one of the most vulnerable are retailers, those who depend on consumers and their spending.
Georgia remains the fifth in terms of budget transparency
According to the 2019 Open Budget Survey (OBS), conducted by the International Budget Partnership (IBP), Georgia got 81 points out of 100 in state budget transparency, the Transparency International Georgia said on Wednesday.
Georgia to receive €1.16 million for agriculture development
Within the GRETA project, the EU, Sweden and Austria launched the Local Development Initiative (LDI), to create great economic opportunities in the organic agriculture sector for farmers, farmer groups, cooperatives, processing units as well as other actors along various organic value chains.
Products rotten amid nationwide lockdown in Georgia
Food chain security is becoming more and more important as lockdown stays in place and farmers cannot transport their products from one place to another.
Georgian government to spend GEL 3.5 billion within crisis management plan
Georgian government has introduced a crisis management plan that consists of different stages. GEL 3.5 billion will be spent to cushion economy but this amount does not cover the post-crisis recovery period.
Georgia to receive €183 million from EU to fight Coronavirus
Due to the economic crisis caused by the pandemic of the coronavirus disease COVID-19, the EU has proposed a new package of macro-financial assistance.
Air traffic to be halted until May 22, GCAA says
Air traffic in Georgia will stay halted until May 22, 2020, Georgian Civil Aviation Agency says in a statement.
Georgian PM discusses support packages from ADB, EBRD
Prime Minister of Georgia Giorgi Gakharia held a video conference with the presidents of the EBRD and ADB regarding the possible assistance and financial resources to be allocated to Georgia due to the challenges associated with the global pandemic.
EBRD to provide €1 billion to Georgia, other countries
The EBRD and Georgia are stepping up cooperation as the country's economy faces the challenge of the coronavirus outbreak – says an official statement published on ebrd.com.
Government closes ski resorts in Georgia over COVID-19
The season at the ski resorts of Georgia closes ahead of schedule, the Prime Minister’s spokesman, Irakli Chikovani, said at a briefing.
Georgia will export armored vehicle Didgori Warrior
A new Georgian armored vehicle Didgori, equipped with a 120mm mobile mortar module, will be exported under the agreement signed between the Military Scientific-Technical Center Delta and one of the countries of the Middle East, the Ministry of Defence said.
Korter: Reliable housing property data in Georgia
It's not a simple job to find fresh homes. But when you use the estate choice service Korter, everything becomes distinct.
Rent a car in Tbilisi – Parent.ge
Are you thinking of booking the best vehicles for your next trip at a very reasonable price? If yes, then this is one of the best decisions you can ever make for yourself.
Pleasant Sunday for the whole family – Renewed Sunday’s brunch at The Biltmore Tbilisi Hotel
Summer, the season of endless fun and vacations, has ended and Tbilisi has become a usually crowded city.
GEL devalues, officials show optimism though
Devaluation of the national currency has sent shockwaves among citizens in Georgia. Officials think that the trend will return to its normal frame, though.
ProCredit Bank’s 20 years of challenges and successes in Georgia and what it means to be a responsible bank
“The bank’s 20-year long presence in Georgia was marked by many challenges and success stories.
Comments on alarming GEL devaluation
The National Bank of Georgia set a new exchange rate, according to which, dollar price became GEL 2.9507 on Tuesday.
Euronews and Silknet sign an MOU to launch “Euronews Georgia”
Euronews and Silknet, Georgia’s leading telecommunications company, are announcing the signing of an MOU in view of launching Euronews Georgia, a news channel and digital platform aimed at a Georgian-speaking audience.
Green Diamond starts to hand over flats to owners as second stage of construction finishes
Second stage of construction of Green Diamond living apartments by MAQRO Construction has finished and process of hand over of flats to owners has started.
Georgian wine tasting in the US came off excellently
Georgian wine tasting in the main cities of the US, New York, Chicago, and Boston went off excellently.
The most wanted fruits from Georgia
The fruit exportation has decreased in Georgia. According to Geostat (National Statistics Office of Georgia), this year, up until May Georgia exported 25 939 300 USD worth of fruit – 6 771 300 USD less than in 2018.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
26.05.2020
27.05.2020
USD
1
USD
3.1916
3.1916
EUR
1
EUR
3.4801
3.4801
GBP
1
GBP
3.8890
3.8890
RUB
100
RUB
4.4615
4.4615
Other Stories
Recently Toyota rolled out Global Campaign under this slogan that reflects the Olympic and Paralympic Spirit of Encouragement,
A couple from Switzerland combines Swiss tradition and technology with Georgian products. Their cheese is made in the Georgian mountains and sold in local stores and hotels.
It has been more than five years since the residents of Lilo village, near Tbilisi, cannot open their windows.
63 000 GEL was received by the Georgian Agro Export Group which is just a small part of the European Neighbourhood Programme for Agricultural and Rural development.
Georgian entrepreneur Guka Tavberidze, who runs his own business in the UK and does it quite well, has been invited by BBC
The grand opening of 7-star The Biltmore Hotel Tbilisi took place in Georgia’s capital on July 31.
DUSHETI, Georgia – The Georgian government and the World Bank will allocate USD 5.6 million (12 million GEL) to fund
A new Georgian clothing brand named Person has emerged in Georgian market.
Georgia is in the midst of an economic maelstrom, Euronews reports.
Situation at Georgia’s mineral water market is interesting: over the last year, the volume of export has grown by 56 percent. According to “GeoStat”, over $114 million worth of mineral water was sold
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
3.1916
EUR
1
EUR
3.4801
GBP
1
GBP
3.8890
RUB
100
RUB
4.4615
May 2020
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31