A Gentlemen’s Agreement without Gentlemen
11 June, 2015
A Gentlemen’s Agreement without Gentlemen
In Search of a Scapegoat

Trust counts the most in any relationship, but in business and politics it is a must. No partnership can work without trust between states or business partners - this is an unwritten code of behavior all over the globe. The terms of gentlemen’s agreement must be observed as accurately as those of official contracts.

Whether or not the IMF asked Ivanishvili to spare Kadagidze the responsibility for his alleged wrongdoings is still a matter of
speculation. The criminal responsibility of Kadagidze is also on the level of verbal suspicion. The only thing that is crystal clear is the fact that Georgian statesmen have lost their reputation in the eyes of the international community and investors alike.

It is an open secret that private information shared during one-on-one dialogues and the gentlemen’s agreements make the basis to important official decisions in future.
If this confidentiality is broken, this means other international partners and diplomats will never share any confidential information with the statesmen of such a country. Investors will keep away from a business climate in which top officials do not understand the importance of the moral code of verbal agreements.
This very shame came over Georgia on June 4, when ex-Prime Minister of Georgia, billionaire Bidzina Ivanishvili disclosed details of his gentlemen’s agreement with the International Monetary Fund’s high-ranking official.
According to Ivanishvili, when he held the post of Prime Minister, a representative of the IMF asked him in a private dialogue not to have Giorgi Kadagidze, Governor of the National Bank of Georgia, arrested. Kadagidze was allegedly involved in a criminal campaign against four banks, including the Cartu Bank, which is owned by Ivanishvili. After his conversation with the IMF representative, Ivanishvili agreed to rescind his claim filed to the Prosecutors’ Office on account of Cartu Bank case.
“The IMF knew that he [Kadagidze] had violated the law. They said they knew that he belonged in jail, but asked me to forgive him. I said I might forgive the private affair that made Javakhishvili [Deputy Minister of Infrastructure and the ex-head of Cartu Bank] extremely upset, but I explained to both the IMF official and Kadagidze that I could not prevent legal actions against him if he had committed a crime against the state,” Ivanishvili stated on June 4.
The IMF resident representative in Georgia did not respond to any calls that day. Next day he rebuffed Ivanishvili’s statement, saying that the IMF “has not taken, and cannot take a view on the issues related to justice and individuals’ relation with the law.”
“This is not our mandate,” the IMF statement reads.
There are speculations in Georgia that in 2006-2012 Kadagidze was involved in anti-banking activity that had deliberately led four banks to bankruptcy. It is largely believed that Kadagidze [who came to the NBG from the Prosecutors’ Office of Georgia] is a friend of the ex-General Prosecutor Zurab Adeishvili, who is wanted by the Georgian state at the moment. Many think that Kadagidze acted under his orders and exerted political pressure on banks that belonged to political rivals of the United National Movement party, which ruled Georgia from autumn of 2003 to autumn of 2012.

“Even as Prime Minister, Ivanishvili had no right to prevent the investigation, as he claims he did, regardless of such a conversation taking place or not”

The list of these four banks is as follows: Standard Bank, owned by the deceased tycoon Badri Patarkatsishvili, People’s Bank, Intellect Bank and Cartu Bank, which is owned by Ivanishvili himself. Allegedly, Kadagidze was involved in all four cases in various capacities: as the Head of the Financial Monitoring Service in 2007-2008, the Head of Financial Supervision Service of the NBG in 2008-2009, and as the Governor of the NBG since 2009.
As the previous owners of the Intellect Bank and Standard Bank say, under the previous government, these banks were deliberately led to bankruptcy and sold out. The People’s Bank stakeholder was forced to sell the controlling package for almost nothing. After Ivanishvili entered the political scene as an opposition member and founded the Georgian Dream party in 2011, a campaign against his Cartu Bank began. Due to legislative changes, the bank lost 150 million GEL and barely escaped bankruptcy.
During his pre-election campaign, Ivanishvili pledged to investigate all banking cases and call Kadagidze to account. Javakhishvili, now an ex-Governor of the NBG, was named as the candidate for Kadagidze’s post.
However, shortly after the power shift in autumn of 2012, when Ivanishvili’s Georgian Dream came into power and he took the Prime Minister’s office, he called Kadagizde “a very smart and talented guy who learns quickly”. Eventually, Kadagidze ended up keeping his post at the NBG. Javakhishvili, who threatened to put him and his team behind bars for all wrongdoings they had committed, fell silent.
Things took a wrong turn for Kadagidze in November of 2014, after Georgian national currency, the lari, started rapidly depreciating. Many economic analysts blamed Kadagidze for the inadequate monetary policy that led to lari losing 34 percent of its value in 8 months. However, neither the Georgian government nor the now former Prime Minister Ivanishvili dropped as much as a single word about Kadagidze’s fault back then.
Even by the end of January, Ivanishvili justified depreciation of the lari, calling it “a healthy behavior in line with the macroeconomic situation in the region”. However, in March Ivanishvili came out with a revelation that the national currency’s depreciation was completely the fault of NBG and Kadagidze’s inadequate monetary policy.
Thus, the smear campaign and the blame game against Kadagidze were launched. The government eagerly heaped the entire responsibility for the lari’s plummeting exchange rate onto him. They reminded the public that Kadagidze was an ally of the former government and has most likely sabotaged the currency. Javakhishvili once again reiterated that Kadagidze belonged in jail.
Kadagidze responded by saying that it was the government’s inadequate budgetary and economic policies that were behind the currency depreciation. He dismissed all accusations against the NBG as pure slander. International financial institutions, including the IMF and the EBRD, backed up the NBG, justified its policy and called on the government to cooperate.
Instead, Ivanishvili disclosed details of the alleged gentlemen’s agreement with the IMF that the IMF later dismissed. In its official statement, the IMF geotv.gereminds how important independence of the NBG is. It also reminds that Georgian authorities have repeatedly reaffirmed their commitment to NBG independence, receiving financial support in return.
“The authorities have reaffirmed their commitment to NBG independence repeatedly. This has allowed the Fund to support Georgia with economic assistance programs, and most recently through the Stand-By Arrangement launched in July 2014,” the IMF states.
This Stand-By Arrangement implies around 150 million USD, and a large part of this sum is already spent. Whether or not the IMF official asked Ivanishvili to spare Kadagidze the responsibility for his alleged wrongdoings is still a matter of speculation. The criminal responsibility of Kadagidze is also on the level of verbal suspicion. According to Irakli Shotadze, Deputy General Prosecutor, there is an ongoing investigation of all the four banks’ cases, including that of Cartu Bank. And if the investigation determines it necessary to interrogate Kadagidze, it will be done.
“If this deal between Ivanishvili and the IMF really took place, it cannot be considered as an agreement between two private persons. It is an interstate agreement, in fact, and once it is violated, there will be consequences,” Levan Alapishvili, a legal expert, told Georgian Journal. “I do not rule out the IMF asking the Georgian government to return the 150 million USD disbursed within the framework of the Stand-By Arrangement last July. Can our budget afford that, I wonder?”
Alapishvili also thinks that Shotadze’s statement has essentially saved Ivanishvili’s questionable adherence to law from scrutiny.
“If not for Shotadze’s statement regarding the banks’ case still being on, we might have gotten to probing Ivanishvili’s term as a PM for law violations. Even as Prime Minister, Ivanishvili had no right to prevent the investigation, as he claims he did, regardless of such a conversation taking place or not” he said.
Whatever Kadagidze’s fault is, he is nevertheless a scapegoat in the lari devaluation story, claims Soso Archvadze, an economic analyst.
“His monetary policy was indeed inadequate, but he alone could not have led lari into such a massive bout of depreciation. The government is obviously trying to shift blame to Kadagidze,” he said.
Despite many questions marks popping up after Ivanishvili’s disclosure, the only thing that is crystal clear is the fact that Georgian statesmen have lost their reputation in the eyes of the international community and investors alike.

Print
Other Stories
Judges that served the violent regime of Saakashvili should not be in the Supreme Court, says Eka Beselia
Eka Beselia, a member of the parliamentary majority, held a press conference in the Parliament today.
Possible confrontation within the Georgian Dream Party?
Eka Beselia, a member of the ruling party, will hold a news conference in the Parliament at 12:00 today.
13 dead from swine flu in Georgia, emergency treatment to be free for all
13 people died from swine flu in Georgia so far, but there is no risk of epidemy, says Georgian Minister of Health.
Georgian president Salome Zurabishvili not ready for launching diplomatic dialogue with Russia
I'm not ready to give any advice to the legislative body about the launch of the diplomatic relations or dialogue with Russia
Georgia suffering the steepest drop in democratic quality in eastern Europe
According to the statistics for the Democracy Index 2018, published by Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU),
“Let’s see if you can wrestle with women”- Interior minister to the opposition
Female Police officers were mobilized in front of the Gurjaani District Court where the case of Davit Kirkitadze, the member of the United Opposition was considered.
Georgian citizens can apply for temporary residency in France
150 permits for young specialists as well as additional 500 permits will be granted each year to go to work to France.
Numbers of Georgians seeking asylum in Germany has significantly decreased
According to Ambassador of Georgia to Germany Elguja Khokrishvili, the drop of asylum requests has been due to recently taken steps.
U.S. Congress supports Georgia with a new bill
Unanimously the U.S. approved the act, which calls for imposing sanctions on Russian actors for the commission of serious human rights abuses in the occupied Georgian territories of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
‘Horn wrestling’ between opposition party leader and police chef
Yesterday on the 16th of December, clashes occurred between Nika Melia, leader of the United National Movement and Teimuraz Kupatadze, head of patrol police department in the village of Velistsikhe, Kakheti region (eastern part of Georgia).
Salome Zourabichvili officially becomes the fifth president of Georgia
The inauguration ceremony of president-elect Salome Zourabichvili took place in Telavi, Kakheti (eastern region of Georgia) on the 16th of December.
Fight erupt in paliament between Georgian MPs during session
Verbal and physical confrontation has occurred between MPs in the parliament.
Famous Georgians invited at the Inauguration of Salome Zourabichvili
The inauguration ceremony of president elect Salome Zourabishvili will be held in Telavi, Kakheti (eastern region of Georgia) on the 16th of December.
Exclusive interview with Lincoln Mitchell, American political analyst and Georgia expert
More than 20,000 people responded to the appeal of the opposition and gathered in front of the former parliament building in downtown Tbilisi last Sunday.
The after-pains of the presidential election in Georgia
Yesterday evening, at a meeting with his supporters in the Philharmonic Hall, the defeated candidate Grigol Vashadze made it clear that he didn’t recognize the result of the presidential elections and called for early parliamentary elections.
National democratic institute publishes their findings about the presidential elections in Georgia
A delegation of the National Democratic Institute, which included observers from five countries, analyzed the election process.
International media about the runoff presidential elections in Georgia
Although it didn’t hit the headlines, newspapers and broadcast around the world report about Salome Zurabishvili as the first woman who became president in Georgia.
100% of the ballot counted: Salome Zourabichvili wins
Yesterday on the 28th of November, the second round of the presidential election took place in Georgia.
Salome Zurabishvili was elected as president of Georgia
According to the CEC, Central Election Committee of Georgia Salome Zurabishvili, an independent candidate endorsed by the ruling Georgian Dream Party, received 59.61 percent of votes.
Preliminary results of runoff election for president in Georgia and clashes in Marneuli
Preliminary results for runoff election for president in Georgia have been announced.
Exit polls say Salome Zurabishvili won runoff election for president in Georgia
Runoff elections for president are over in Georgia. Voting booths were closed at 8 pm Tbilisi time. Some exit polls have already been published.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs about the shooting in Chumlaki
Today on the 28th of November, the second round of the presidential election takes place in Georgia.
Second round of presidential elections in Georgia
Georgians head to the polls for a runoff election for president. The first round was held on the 28th of October,
The 15th Anniversary of Georgia’s Rose Revolution
15 years ago, in 2003, the rose revolution took place in Georgia.
Unprecedented move by Cartu Group to nullify debts for 600 000 Georgian citizens
The Prime Minister of Georgia Mamuka Bakhtadze announced on the 19th of November that the bank debt of over 600,000 Georgian citizens, including those on a so-called ‘Black List’ will be annulled.
PHOTO OF THE DAY

Exchange Rates
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
15.01.2019
16.01.2019
USD
1
USD
2.6650
2.6644
EUR
1
EUR
3.0546
3.0449
GBP
1
GBP
3.4227
3.4203
RUB
100
RUB
3.9631
3.9687
Other Stories
On 26 May, Jean-Claude Juncker, President of the European Commission, joined celebrations in the Georgian capital of Tbilisi
Violation of Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity by Assad regime has been strictly criticized
Exactly one year ago, Georgia was granted visa-free travel with the European Union.
Georgia’s ex-president president Mikheil Saakashvili's supporters managed to free detained Mikheil Saakashvili in the center of Kiev.
The US Ambassador to Georgia Ian Kelly congratulates Georgia on Independence Day.
The regulations on the introduction of visa-free travel for citizens of Georgia have been officially signed in Brussels.
The entire Georgia is involved in Secret Santa game, which means that people are sending gifts to each other secretly
The Minister of Foreign Affairs of Georgia is taking part in NATO Ministerial underway in Brussels, Belgium.
A special squad has been mobilized at the 48th polling station in Marneuli, Kvemo Kartli region.
Two politicians in Georgia have come to blows during a live TV debate ahead of the country’s parliamentary elections, Euronews reports.
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.6644
EUR
1
EUR
3.0449
GBP
1
GBP
3.4203
RUB
100
RUB
3.9687
January 2019
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31