BSEC Summit – B Is for Blame Games
30 May, 2017
BSEC Summit – B Is for Blame Games
Now, first things first: Despite the headlines that some of the Georgian media gleefully rolled forth last week, it wasn’t Vice PM Kumsishvili’s idea to get up and stand beside the Russian PM Medvedev in a group, or as they prefer us to call it, a family photo. If anything, he was late to attend and rather stone-faced. Nor so did an earlier meeting between the two take place, as much as the abovementioned Georgian media would like us to
believe. How do I know that? Well, officially Medvedev had two meetings – one with the Turkish side and another with Moldovan President Igor Dodon. Could an unofficial meeting take place? Let’s indulge the thought, but it’s hardly believable – Both arrived late to Istanbul and Medvedev’s press aides spent the whole day with us except for those two meetings. In conclusion – we may pride ourselves in having the best ‘freedom of the press’ levels in the region, but when it comes to truthful reporting, we still have a long way to go.

With that little scandal dealt with, let’s go on to what actually happened at BSEC (Organization of the Black Sea Economic Cooperation) 25 Anniversary summit, which, courtesy of the Turkish embassy in Georgia, I was able to attend. First, here is some trivia for you: It first came into existence in 1992, became what it is today in 1999, has 12 members (all Black Sea countries plus Albania, Serbia, Greece, Moldova, Armenia and Azerbaijan) and is essentially the biggest regional platform for Economic cooperation. Economy is the key word here: with all political and in some cases, military turmoil, that has been plaguing the region for decades now.

Right, sure. As you well know, it is virtually impossible to separate politics and economics these days, and such an approach results in increasingly limited room to maneuver into and even more of a limited scope for cooperation. Remember Krylov’s “The Swan, The Pike and The Crab”? – Well, this is exactly what took place at the 25 Anniversary summit, with the notable distinction that there were sides that seemed to be unwilling to move at all.

They say a summit is only as good as its declaration – actually, no, I just made it up; but thing is it was the concluding declaration of the summit that proved to be the Gordian knot for the participants. On one hand, it was Georgia and the Ukraine who were vocal against Russia; on another- Armenia and Azerbaijan, traditionally unwilling to bury the proverbial hatchet. The Georgia Ukraine alliance wanted to put in a paragraph denouncing Russia’s aggressive actions in the region, while the Azerbaijan v.s. Armenia standoff ascended to the heights of Monty Pythonian absurdity, with Azerbaijani deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mahmud Mamedgulyev dutifully informing us (direct quote): “it’s them Armenians again, as always, they are keen to undermine everything we want to work together on in the region.” Which, as his Armenian counterpart, Ashot Ovakimian thought, (direct quote) was “ nonsense, as usual from Azerbaijanis”. One thing they seemed both in agreement on though was the importance of retaining cooperation with the European Union. While discussing ongoing talks over visa facilitation procedures, both underlined that this was something the people of both nations wanted and were looking forward to. As for the Ukraine, which will already enjoy visa free travel as of June 11, it was an occasion to remind the leaders of the region that War in Eastern Ukraine is far from over and indeed to point a finger over to the main culprit – Russia. Indeed, Kiev’s top diplomat, FM Pavlo Klimkin, was one of the more forthcoming and outspoken journalists at an otherwise very much media restricted, behind closed doors kind of event. His rather blunt borderline sarcastic commentary is perhaps best analyzed for understating and highlighting the challenges that the BSEC organization is currently facing:

“When you ask me whether I expect significant decisions to be made at this summit, I’ll have to say that no, regrettably I don’t have such expectations. Why? Because we have a catastrophic situation when it comes to security in the Black Sea region. All thanks to Russia, which is behind most conflicts and instability in the region. We need to sort out these security issues somehow. I told my colleagues today that the BSEC organization is in deep crisis and we need to try and find a way to move forward. Our principal position regarding the declaration is that international values and international rights should be safeguarded and adhered to. That’s something we will not and cannot compromise on. Quite understandably, we do not view Russia as a feasible partner in economics, or in any sense a trustworthy partner, truth be told. And without trust, you cannot build cooperation, economic or otherwise. “

In the end, it fell to into the responsibility of the hosts – the Turkish side -to mediate a declaration, which they successfully did – Despite the statements that the returning Georgian delegation gave to the media, notions akin of “Aggression by Russia” and “breach of international law” did not make it into the final draft (look out for that and many more during the upcoming Ukrainian chairmanship), which underlined the importance of BSEC itself as the highest level discussion and consensus finding body over economic cooperation issues in the region. It calls on all sides to respect international law, maintain safety of navigation in the Black Sea region (Russia signed this? The gall!), commends the contribution of all involved sides, mentions the importance of the cooperation with the EU, issues like shipping, innovation, young entrepreneurs’ – pretty much every subject that all concerned couldn’t start a fight over. Some might call it a generic document, yet there will be others who will hail it as a compromise found amid adversity and a future reference point. 25 years of consensus, maintaining the ever shifting scale of balance – a feat not to be dismissed. A feat BSEC seemed able to pull off thus far, but the question is – for how long?

By Vazha Tavberidze

Source: Georgia Today
Other Stories
Saakashvili as an Inspiration
His reputation has certainly been somewhat diminished in Georgia (and Ukraine), but it appears that Ex-President Saakashvili’s divisive persona still fascinates people
Main achievement in 2017 was visa-free travel with EU, says PM
The main achievement in the European and Euro-Atlantic integration in 2017 was the visa-free travel with the EU,
French Ambassador on Politics, Wine and the Good & Bad of Georgia
Franco-Georgian relations, you can argue, are centuries old,
White House states Russia violated the sovereignty of Georgia and Ukraine
The US National Security Strategy, published by the White House yesterday, concerns the issue of Georgia too.
Mikheil Saakashvili decides to stop rallies and marches in Ukraine
Ex-President of Georgia Mikheil Saakashvili made a decision to stop rallies and marches in Ukraine.
Mikheil Saakashvili – I‘m ready to become the PM of Ukraine, but the President of Ukraine should be Ukrainian
Former President of Georgia and former Governor of Odessa district Mikheil Saakashvili
NATO asks Russia to pull out from Abkhazia and South Ossetia, promises membership to Georgia
NATO Foreign Ministers reaffirmed their practical and political support for Georgia on December 6
Saakashvili to begin impeachment of Poroshenko - Georgia's ex-president adresses his supporters
Former President of Georgia Mikheil Saakashvili has addressed his supporters
"We have a comprehensive reform plan for 2020, which will enable us to draw even closer to Europe" – Georgian PM
The Eastern Partnership Summit has concluded. Georgia’s success has been pointed out unanimously.
EU Council President says Georgia is reliable and exemplary partner of EU
Prime Minister of Georgia Giorgi Kvirikashvili has started his visit to Brussels and met with European Council President Donald Tusk.
Giorgi Margvelashvili does not rule out the possibility to run again for presidency
President of Georgia Giorgi Margvelashvili does not rule out the possibility to run again for presidency.
US Ambassador respects Georgia’s right to make its own decisions about security issues
Georgia is a sovereign country and we respect its right to make its own decisions about its own defense,
EU Council adopts regulation for entry-exit system for third country nationals
The Council of Europe has made a final decision on adoption of the regulation for the entry-exit system and regulation amending the Schengen border
US Ambassador does not recognize borders mentioned by de-facto president of occupied Tskhinvali Region
"We do not recognize the borders mentioned by Mr. Bibilov, - the United States Ambassador to Georgia Ian Kelly said
EU Parliament says Georgia, Ukraine, Moldova could be considered for EU membership
Nine days prior to the start of Eastern Partnership Summit, the European Parliament called for deepening the European integration of Ukraine, Georgia and Moldova
Ex-minister about the integration of Georgia’s ministries of Environment and Agriculture
It seems strange that the Ministry of Environment is being weakened shortly after the elections of local self-governments
Mattis, Georgia’s Defense Minister Discuss Security Issues at Pentagon
A meeting held between United States Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis and Georgian Defense Minister Levan Izoria aiming to discuss security issues and U.S.- Georgian security partnership
EU welcomes 16th consolidated report on Conflict in Georgia
The EU welcomes the Secretary-General’s 16th consolidated report on Conflict in Georgia.
Georgian government launches Abkhazian Language Protection and Development Program
The Georgian government has been working on establishment of the Abkhazian Language Protection and Development State Program,
Mike Goldwater on the Day Georgia “Lost” Abkhazia
September 27, the day Sokhumi fell to Abkhazian troops, remains one of the darkest leaves in Georgia’s modern history.
EU welcomes change of Entry/Exit System for stronger EU borders
The European Commission has issued the following statement after today’s adoption by the European Parliament
US Embassy congratulates Georgia on well-administered local elections
The Embassy of the United States congratulates the government and people of Georgia on yesterday’s well-administered local elections,
All polling stations data counted, Kakha Kaladze gains 51,13% of the votes
As reported by Georgia’s Central Election Commission,
Ex- Milan defender Kakha Kaladze becomes new Tbilisi Mayor
On October 21 Mayoral and city council elections were held in Georgia.
Alexandre Elisashvili congratulates Kakhi Kaladze on victory
Anyone should be able to recognize the election results.
GEL Exchange Rate
Other Stories
Georgia’s ex-president president Mikheil Saakashvili's supporters managed to free detained Mikheil Saakashvili in the center of Kiev.
The US Ambassador to Georgia Ian Kelly congratulates Georgia on Independence Day.
The regulations on the introduction of visa-free travel for citizens of Georgia have been officially signed in Brussels.
The entire Georgia is involved in Secret Santa game, which means that people are sending gifts to each other secretly
The Minister of Foreign Affairs of Georgia is taking part in NATO Ministerial underway in Brussels, Belgium.
A special squad has been mobilized at the 48th polling station in Marneuli, Kvemo Kartli region.
Two politicians in Georgia have come to blows during a live TV debate ahead of the country’s parliamentary elections, Euronews reports.
The Georgian President and his wife are on a state visit to Israel. Giorgi Magvelashvili and the First Lady, together
Koba Subeliani, a member of the National Movement party and the parliamentary minority
According to Prime Minister Irakli Gharibashvili, the Georgian side will take part in the UN peacekeeping mission.
GEL Exchange
January 2018
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31