Georgian Democratic Republic & Russian White Movement
06 September, 2010
Georgian Democratic Republic & Russian White Movement

In 1918, 1919 and 1920 the Georgian military units were compelled to confront the Russian general Denikin's forces on the one hand and the Bollshevik forces on the other. Those forces alternated with each other. Professor Simon Maskharashvili has more  to say.

In 1918, 1919 and 1920 the Georgian military units were compelled to confront the Russian general Denikin's forces on the one hand and the Bollshevik forces on the other. Those forces alternated with each other. Professor Simon Maskharashvili has

more  to say.

GJ - May 26 of 1918 is stipulated in history as the birthday of the Georgian independent democratic republic although the Georgian independent state had lasted only three years, and even those three years were politically very strained. In addition to that, Georgia was permanently fighting the military forces of various countries. And the Menshevik government made plenty of mistakes in the process of building a new country, which resulted in the dramatic events finalized by the annexation of Georgia by the Bolshevik Russia. What was the actual situation like? What were the first steps made by the independent state of Georgia? 

SM - As I said, the national Council elected Noah Ramishvili a chairman of the Georgian government on May 26 of 1918. He was the most nationalist-minded politician among the Georgian Mensheviks. This fact must have seriously irritated most of the Georgian partocracy.

GJ - Which partocracy do you mean?

SM - I mean the social-democrats who came to power and grabbed the reigns of ruling the country. Just in a month's time after the election, commander-in-chief of the people's guard Valiko Jugeli sent a message to chairman Noah Ramishvili to immediately retire or else his guard would enter Tbilisi and depose him by force. At least, this is what the legend has, but the story has a very realistic sounding. Valiko Jugeli was not subordinated to the ministry of defense of Georgia. He represented the force which the Menshvik party of Georgia was relying on and the orders of which he would obey unquestionably. Noah Ramishvili had retired indeed and was substituted by the former chairman of the Georgian National Council Noah Zhordania. He was more loyal to Russia than his predecessor, giving preference to socialist ideals compared to nationalist ones. Very soon in the summer of 1918, the situation became strained at the Russia-Georgian border, namely in Abkhazeti (Abkhazia). Russians made an attempt to invade Abkhazeti. In 1918, 1919 and 1920 the Georgian military units were compelled to confront the Russian general Denikin's forces on the one hand and the Bolshevik forces on the other.

GJ - When you say Denikin's forces you probably mean the Russian White Guard. Can you briefly explain what the White Guard means?

SM - That was the politico-military force of the Russian White Movement which unsuccessfully fought the Bolsheviks after the October Revolution. When Kerenski's provisional government was ousted in St. Petersburg in Russia, the power went to Bolsheviks, alias communists. But this happened only in St. Petersburg, the Capital of Russia. 75% of the territory of what is now the Russian federation was found in the hands of the Bolsheviks' opponents, but that was not exactly a unified force. Somewhere the Mensheviks and the SR's (Socialist Revolutionary Party) took over - they were the winners in the elections of the Founding Assembly of the first Russian parliament although they lasted only one day - they were kicked out from St. Petersburg by the Bolsheviks. In some corners of Russia the Cossack atamans were the leaders. In other places the monarchists had the power, and still somewhere else - the Cadets (Constitutional Democrats). Those were the dispersed and isolated forces. Centralization of the anticommunist movement in Russia took place only in November of 1918 when Germany was defeated in the First World War and England, France and America got involved more actively in the Russian internal affairs. In other words, until the Triple Entente member countries (United Kingdom, France and the Russian Empire) were engaged in the war with Germany, Russia so to speak, was left to her own devices, and the international powers had not much of an influence on her, excluding Germany, with which the Bolshevik Russia arranged truce in Brest on March 3 of 1918.

GJ - What did the truce envisage?

SM - With that truce, Russia ceded the entire Baltic Sea coast countries, Belarus, Bessarabia and Ukraine to Germany. There were many other issues though, which Russia was at that moment induced to handle in favor of Germany.

GJ - How are these two phenomena connected - the consolidation of anti-Bolshevik movement and the international influence on Russia?

SM - These two things are directly associated. There was no power looming in Russia which could have consolidated anti-Bolshevik movement there. That's why this role was supposed to be played by an external power - another country. For the White Russian General Denikin and the selfsame Russian Founding Assembly members, the Bolshevik-made Brest Truce with Germany was not acceptable. Had they won the confrontation with Bolsheviks, they would have cancelled the Brest Truce, thus declaring the act of ceding the Russian Empire territories to Germany null and void. This would have certainly been against the German will. This is why between March and November of 1918 the Bolsheviks were the most acceptable force for the Germans. The Triple Entente member countries had no time to deal with Russia at that moment. Hence there was lack of readiness for consolidating the anti-Bolshevik forces. In November of 1918, Britain and France brought to Tomsk of Siberia Admiral Kolchak, the former scientist.

They assisted him in every possible way to let him establish his dictatorship there. Kolchak declared himself a supreme ruler of Russia, and he was recognized by every member of the Triple Entente as a de jure ruler of Russia. Thus the White Movement leaders, Generals Kolchak and Vrangel were considered by the West as de jure heads of state of Russia between November of 1918 and March of 1921 - until signing the trade agreement between the Russia's Bolshevik government and England. And the agreement itself meant the actual recognition of the Russian Bolshevik government on part of Britain.

GJ - You said that the government of the independent Georgia and its military units were compelled to fight at the Russian-Georgian border with the White Guard as well as with Bolsheviks . . .

SM - In being against Georgia, both the White Movement and the Bolsheviks were unanimous.

GJ - What they were unanimous about? About keeping Georgia part of the Russian Empire?

SM - Just as Poland, Baltic Sea coast countries, Finland, Ukraine and Belarus! In 1920, the West which was helping Denikin and Kolchak against Bolsheviks, suggested to Poland and Finland to strengthen the help to the Russian White Guard generals in exchange of the independence those countries had acquired with the help of the West. Poland and Finland had categorically refused to do so. In consequence, the West had finally lost the desire and readiness to provide any help to the Russian White Guard because if they defeated the Bolsheviks, they would again raise the issue of restoring the Russian Empire.

GJ - Which was very much beyond the plans of the West, wasn't it?

SM - Of course!

 

Print
Other Stories
Georgia to ban flights from China, evacuate citizens from Wuhan
Health Minister Ekaterine Tikaradze says that flights will be banned from China and the Georgian citizens will be evacuated from Wuhan.
Georgia to suspend direct flights from China, as toll from Coronavirus exceeds 100
Georgia will suspend direct flights with China, Minister of Economy Natia Turnava said on Tuesday.
Video of South Korean girl in Budapest speaking perfect Georgian is going viral
South Korean girl in Budapest spoke perfect Georgian when asked about what she liked most about Georgia. Video was uploaded on Facebook and has tens of thousands views.
Ministry of Health started checking citizens on coronavirus at Tbilisi international airport
Preventative measures in Tbilisi International Airport against deadly Coronavirus has already been made.
As coronavirus takes momentum, Georgia takes countermeasures
The flight from China to Georgia has been canceled today. Deputy Minister of Health Tamar Gabunia said that the flight was canceled at the initiative of the Chinese side, but the reason is unknown.
Teaching process suspended in 17 schools due to heavy snowfall in Adjara
Due to heavy snowfall, classes have been suspended in 17 schools of the mountainous villages of Adjara region due to heavy snow. The Ministry of Education, Science and Culture says that pupils could not arrive at schools.
Transparency International: Georgia ranks top in CPI in the Eastern Europe and Central Asia region
Georgia has been assigned a score of 56 and shares 44th place with Costa Rica, the Czech Republic, and Latvia
Stray dog helps children cross the road in Batumi, Georgia
ABC News has published a video recorded in Batumi that shows how a stray dog helps kids to cross the road.
What makes Georgian fashion distinctive?
Georgian fashion and designers is becoming more and more recognizable, but what makes them unique?
NDI: Majority of Georgians support EU, NATO membership
Recent poll results released by the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and CRRC Georgia revealed that the majority of respondents approve of the Government’s goal for Georgia to become a member of the European Union (EU) and NATO.
NDI: Majority of Georgians say no political party is “closest to them”
The U.S. National Democratic Institute (NDI) has today released the results of its public opinion survey. According to the survey, majority of the respondents say “no political party” is “closest to them”.
Human Rights Watch: Impunity for abuse by law enforcement officials remaines a persistent problem in Georgia
Impunity for abuse by law enforcement officials remained a persistent problem, - reads the Human Rights Watch Report 2020.
HRW 2020 report: media landscape shaken, labour law still not sufficiently regulated in Georgia
Human Rights Watch has published its 2020 report. The report includes information about media, judicial and political environment in Georgia.
British Ambassador congratulates Georgian people on Kalanda
British Ambassador to Georgia Justin McKenzie Smith congratulates Georgian people on Kalanda - Old style New Year.
Civil Aviation Agency calls on airlines registered in Georgia to refrain from using the airspace of Iran and Iraq
Georgia's Civil Aviation Agency calls on airlines registered in Georgia to refrain from using the airspace of Iran and Iraq
Georgia celebrates orthodox Christmas
Christmas in Georgia and in the Orthodox Christian countries is celebrated on the 7th of January. Part of the celebration is traditional Alilo March.
Mayor Kakha Kaladze switches on Christmas Tree in Tbilisi
Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze opened main Christmas tree in Tbilisi on the 25th of December. The tree was made in Milan and costs 304 848 Euros.
Pope Francis invites Georgian Patriarch Ilia II to Vatican
Pope Francis has sent a letter to Catholicos-Patriarch of All Georgia Ilia II and commemorated the Patriarch's hospitality during his visit to Georgia three years ago.
Death of 15 years old Luka Siradze sparks controversies in Georgia
Opposition parties have issued a joint statement expressing their condolences over the death of 15 years old Luka Siradze.
Premiere of the film “And then we danced” to be held amid possible unrest
The premiere of the 2019 Swedish-Georgian drama film - And Then We Danced, directed by Levan Akin, is scheduled to be held at Tbilisi and Batumi cinemas today.
Explosion after Possible gas leak in Tbilisi
A natural gas leak is the suspected cause of an explosion that destroyed the part of a multi-storey residential building on Guramishvili Avenue in Tbilisi.
Exclusive interview with Gail Elliott
The name of Gail Elliott is known to anyone. She was among supermodels Naomi Campbell, Cindy Crawford, Helena Christensen and Claudia Schiffer in the 1990s.
Mountaineer and pioneer: Nick Erkomaishvili
In 1989 Nick Erkomaishvili and some friends agreed to guide a group of Swiss climbers to Mount Kazbek. This encounter led them to become the first Georgian tour operators. And they founded the one and only Georgian Mountain Guide School.
Police in Tbilisi detain 11 for child pornography
The Ministry of Internal Affairs has arrested 11 members of a criminal group on the charges of child trafficking and pornography.
“She had schizophrenia” – Mother of the perpetrator of the 3-year-old boy speaks out
On the 27th of August in Tbilisi an unknown woman suddenly approached to a three-year-old boy, walking with his parents and sister, and harmed his face with sharp instrument and escaped.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
27.01.2020
28.01.2020
USD
1
USD
2.8870
2.8944
EUR
1
EUR
3.1870
3.1914
GBP
1
GBP
3.7823
3.7893
RUB
100
RUB
4.6730
4.6313
Other Stories
World famous British singer Jessie J has decided to wear clothes made by Anouki Areshidze, Georgian designer and wife of the mayor of Tbilisi.
Bassiani, one of the most popular underground clubs not only in Georgia but throughout Europe as well, has opened today
An amazing video made in Georgia by tourists from the Philippines have gone viral on the internet.
Over the recent two days May 12-13 Tbilisi city saw a peaceful protest rally in the center of the city.
Hundreds of people took to the main street Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi to protest the raid in Tbilisi’s popular night clubs.
Two bear cubs listed as endangered on the red list were handed over to Tbilisi Zoo,
Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze and Deputy Tbilisi Mayor Ms. Sophio Khuntsaria have gifted a food stand
Pamela Anderson, famous Canadian American actress and model has appeared in the chic sunglasses by internationally acclaimed Georgian designer George Keburia.
A ski lift accident in Georgia’s eastern Gudauri resort,in particular at Sadzele 5 lift, has left 8 people with injuries.
The ski lift in Gudauri winter resort in Georgia has broke down in the aftermath of which several people have been injured.
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.8870
EUR
1
EUR
3.1870
GBP
1
GBP
3.7823
RUB
100
RUB
4.6730