Fiasco of First Five-Year Plan and Start of Repressions
30 December, 2010
Fiasco of First Five-Year Plan and Start of Repressions

It had not taken Stalin too long to put all the responsibility for every failure on the shoulders of Intelligentsia – the old guard of specialists and scientists. He stigmatized them as ‘public enemies’, harm-doers’ and ‘Trotskyites’ who presumably wanted to deliberately trigger the discontent in the public, thus instigating the confrontation between the people and the Soviet Power. Professor Simon Maskharashvili has more.
GJ – The first five-year plan, made by Stalin and the Soviet authorities failed to be fulfilled.

The economic reforms suggested by them had not given any results, but the government was still responsible to explain the failure to the people, wasn’t it?
SM – Yes, the first five-year plan was a complete fiasco – the country-side was simply devastated, the industry in the urban areas was at a standstill, the old equipment in factories and mills were falling out of commission and the new equipment was nowhere to come from. Peasants were hungry, workers were discontent, and the fear for survival was overwhelming among the populace. Stalin knew quite well what the matter was, but he would never own up the failure. A scapegoat was to be found in the situation. And the reasons of failure had to be explained to people. And the authorities were supposed to perceive ‘correctly’ the reasons of failure of the young Soviet state. This would at least make way for the fulfillment of the next five-year plan.
GJ – And who was that scapegoat?
SM – Stalin blamed the Intelligentsia – the old guard of specialists and scientist – in deliberate spreading of various diseases of plants and animals which had triggered the crisis in agriculture. He insisted that the harm-doers were breaking the factory machinery intentionally. He was trying to prove that bad projects that were created would keep the intended constructions from implementation. He stigmatized the Intelligentsia as ‘public enemies’, harm-doers’ and ‘Trotskyites’ who presumably wanted to deliberately trigger the discontent in the public, thus instigating the confrontation between the people and the Soviet Power. Such was the myth which Stalin had fabricated to justify his failed policies.
GJ – Did the Soviet people believe the myth?
SM – Somebody believed and somebody didn’t. It so happened that even the authorities - at least part of them – did not believe a word of the story. In a word, in 1932 a lot of specialists, labeled as ‘harm-doers’ and ‘public enemies’ were apprehended, many of them were shot and many were exiled, but this was followed by certain confrontations on part of the political elite. Incidentally, many of those specialists were not the ones who were functioning in the Tsarist Russia. The information about the 1932 arrests reached Abel Enukidze who was not a great liberal or an enthused champion of the Georgian Cause. He used to be an ethnic Georgian working in the Kremlin as secretary of the Central Executive Committee and monitored the Kremlin security system as a major party autocrat. What he did was that he simply informed the Politburo member Sergo Orjonikidze about the vain arrest of several persons. By Sergo’s order, there came to Georgia the investigator of special cases Lenin’s sister Mariam Ulyanova to revise some of the indictments. After having talked with one of  the apprehended people (I am talking about my great grand father), she let go free about 2000 persons. 
GJ – So, Ulyanova found out that those people were arrested without any reason for that . . .  
SM – She clearly saw that criminal cases were fabricated against them and she ordered to immediately set free the prisoners. This fact is just about enough to make a conclusion that in the years between 1932 and 1934 there appeared clear signs of rift within Stalin’s regime. Many people understood that the mechanism of the Stalinist rule was faulty. Rural and urban areas were devastated, the industry was working just on the production of combat weapons, and standard of living was stagnated at a critical level. The only goal Stalin pursued was invasion of the world to rule it all by his own volition.   
GJ – Although Stalin was an indisputable leader of the Soviet state, it still sounds inconceivable that this was all the whims and mistakes of just one person . . .
SM – He was certainly not alone. Next to him were Molotov, Voroshilov, Mikoyan and others who remained faithful to him right to the end. There were also people in his entourage who thought that Stalin’s doings were wrong and ugly. 
GJ – Where there any old Bolsheviks and revolutionaries who tried to defy the Stalinist ways?
SM – Certainly! Those were self-same Kamenev, Zinoviev, Enukidze and some others, who had already achieved perfect standard of living and could not very well perceive Stalin’s actions. They could not understand what Stalin had wanted after all. Maybe he wished to create the Soviet Socialist Republics of the World with the Russian language as the dominant tongue. Who knows! There were other nuances too which had triggering confusion among Stalin’s fellow- revolutionaries. Stalin adored Lisenko, for example.
GJ – But who was that Lisenko?
SM – He was a scientist working on changing the direction of genetics in science. He came up with the theory of altering the functions of species.
GJ – Why was the Soviet Leader so fascinated with Lisenko’s ideas? He must have had a reason for this . . . SM – Here is what Lisenko was working on specifically: he would freeze a seed of a plant which was indigenous in the south, and then tried to let it grow in the North. There was a slight possibility of success in the experiment, but only in case of certain plants, notwithstanding the quality of the received fruit of course. Extrapolating this method on every plant and finally on humans, was totally unjustified.
GJ – What do you mean by ‘humans’? Were they experimenting on people too? 
SM – That was the gist of the idea. This is exactly why Stalin liked and venerated Lisenko. Let’s now imagine the development of the Lisenko theory in social practice. Take for example, an ethnic Georgian of an aristocratic descent who is also a progeny of a prominent scientist. If through Lisenko’s experiment he was made oblivious of all these facts about him and got used instead to the idea that he was a Russian and also a child of a Russian worker, finally planted in the Russian environment, the subject of the experiment would form into a typical Russian person. Eventually, the life and the genetics proved that this may not happen so easily. One can achieve some success to a certain extent but people who are bred in the incubator would never be the same qualitative personalities as those who grew up in natural circumstance. Moreover, the result may not be achieved at all – an individual may not even become a personality at all, even on a biological level. Stalin died having never abandoned the idea.
GJ – Does this mean that Stalin wanted to utterly stereotype the Soviet citizens? 
SM – Probably! He wanted to create a new type of a Russian, a Soviet person and desired to spread this theory all over the world. He was nursing that idea of invading the entire world.

Print
Other Stories
International Festival of classical music to be held in Batumi
At the end of this week an International Festival of classic music will kick off for the 6th time in Batumi, Georgia’s beautiful seaside city.
Georgians who beat the world record
There are many Georgians among the world recordsmen. Georgians managed to beat the world record for 78 times to date. Today we explore four of them.
Jenny Brunt speaks about Georgia with Georgian Journal
Jenny Brunt is among the most famous models worldwide. She used to be on the covers of different international magazines in the 1990s.
Tako Natsvlishvili wearing Pain de Sucre - photographed by David Bellemere
Tako Natsvlishvili is a 19-yeal old model from Georgia. She has recently been photographed by a prominent French photographer David Bellemere.
Former Georgian plastic surgeon who owns a restaurant in New York
Maia Acquaviva is a Georgian former surgeon, who worked in one of the clinics here in Tbilisi, but decided to go to the USA and start a business there.
David Beckham first saw Victoria Adams in Tbilisi
Tbilisi is truly a magical city. It brings many people and cultures together, even connects future spouses. Do you think we are joking? Not at all.
Georgia should be at the top of every travel destination list – says German photographer about Georgia
The German Chancellor Angela Merkel visits Georgia tomorrow and possibly as a result of this visit the German media is currently writing a lot about Georgia.
Alexander Julakidze - Georgian pianist based in Jerusalem
A well-known Georgian pianist Alexander Julakidze has successfully participated in a variety of piano competitions. He currently lives in Jerusalem, Israel contributing to Georgia’s popularity all over the world.
Anna Kendrick in David Koma’s dress
The readers of the Georgian Journal will definitely have heard about David Koma, a young and talented Georgian designer based in London.
Medical tourism increases in Georgia
In the first quarter of 2018, Georgia was visited by 13 900 foreigners for medical and recovery purposes. The level is 61.2 % higher than the same period in 2017.
Rebellious and successful Georgian model based in Barcelona
Remember we told you a story this week about a Georgian model Paloma Anastasia Mikadze, who currently is based in Barcelona and is quite successful there?
Georgian Rubik’s Cube solver Vako Marchilashvili breaks the Guinness World Record
Vako Marchilashvili is a young Rubik’s Cube solver from Georgia. He participated in “Georgia’s Got Talent 2017 “and introduced his genius abilities to the Georgian public.
Turkish born Georgian sisters sing a beautiful song
There are many Georgians, who live in Turkey, but maintain Georgian culture and heritage.
What types of transport can Georgia offer tourists?
Train, subway, bus, mini-bus, taxi and airplane – these are the types of transport that Georgia can offer tourists.
Chris Botti to perform in Georgia
American trumpeter Chris Botti arrived in Georgia yesterday. Today the musician is due to perform with the Georgian singer Nani Bregvadze.
Georgian schoolchildren create Robot “Vano”
Georgian students from the Guivy Zaldastanishvili American Academy in Tbilisi have created a robot named Vano.
Khatia Buniatishvili performs with the Estonian Festival Orchestra at the Proms in London
On the 13th of August, Paavo Järvi and the Estonian Festival Orchestra performed at the Royal Albert Hall in London during its famous Proms season.
Paloma Anastasia Mikadze, an Instagram star from Georgia
Anastasia Mikadze is a Georgian social network star from Georgia. She shares her ideas about fashion, interior design and healthy lifestyle with hundreds of followers on Instagram.
Georgian lifeguard who saved life of nearly 700 people
Gocha Bilvanidze, the Head of the Maritime Rescue Service has been with the organization for eight years now. He has saved the lives of around 700 people during that time.
Children of Georgian migrant to the USA Parten Chikviladze (Peter Chiglo) visit Georgia
A 16-year Parten Chikviladze from Racha (the western part of Georgia) left Georgian 1913 for America, never to return back.
 Surprising proposal by a Georgian Soldier
The video of a Georgian Cadet Soldier’s proposal to his girlfriend has gone viral on the social media. He proposed to her in the presence of other soldiers in front of the Academy.
The 10th anniversary of the 2008 war through a young graphic designer’s eye
A 23-year old Nika Chalakhshasvhili is a graphic designer from Georgia. He has created some interesting illustrations to express his protest against the Russian occupation of Georgian territory:
Georgian policewomen: stereotypes and reality
The number of female members in the Security Forces is increasing year after year.
Georgian entrant who got top marks in two subjects
Devi Oniani is a graduate of the 55th Public School, Tbilisi, Georgia.
What is behind the collection “Family and War” by Demna Gvasalia
A Georgian fashion designer, the Creative Director of Balenciaga and Head Designer at Vetements, presented a collection named “Family and War” during Paris Fashion Week.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
Exchange Rates
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
17.09.2018
18.09.2018
USD
1
USD
2.6128
2.6156
EUR
1
EUR
3.0578
3.0498
GBP
1
GBP
3.4296
3.4259
RUB
100
RUB
3.8669
3.8379
Other Stories
World famous British singer Jessie J has decided to wear clothes made by Anouki Areshidze, Georgian designer and wife of the mayor of Tbilisi.
Bassiani, one of the most popular underground clubs not only in Georgia but throughout Europe as well, has opened today
An amazing video made in Georgia by tourists from the Philippines have gone viral on the internet.
Over the recent two days May 12-13 Tbilisi city saw a peaceful protest rally in the center of the city.
Hundreds of people took to the main street Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi to protest the raid in Tbilisi’s popular night clubs.
Two bear cubs listed as endangered on the red list were handed over to Tbilisi Zoo,
Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze and Deputy Tbilisi Mayor Ms. Sophio Khuntsaria have gifted a food stand
Pamela Anderson, famous Canadian American actress and model has appeared in the chic sunglasses by internationally acclaimed Georgian designer George Keburia.
A ski lift accident in Georgia’s eastern Gudauri resort,in particular at Sadzele 5 lift, has left 8 people with injuries.
The ski lift in Gudauri winter resort in Georgia has broke down in the aftermath of which several people have been injured.
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.6156
EUR
1
EUR
3.0498
GBP
1
GBP
3.4259
RUB
100
RUB
3.8379
September 2018
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30