Much Ado about…the Memorial
22 December, 2017
Much Ado about…the Memorial
The recently-removed memorial to victims of the Georgia–Abkhazia war in the Scottish town of Kilmarnock will be reinstalled unchanged, reports OC Media, a local news outlet. Kilmarnock authorities have apparently declared that the memorial will remain as it is until “universally acceptable alternative wording and content” can be agreed by all sides. For those not privy to this business, it is the very same memorial, the removal of which was a couple of weeks ago emphatically announced by the Georgian
Embassy in London as a diplomatic victory, as the memorial sported the “national” flag of Abkhazia. What transpired further would not look out of place in a script for a new season of the celebrated British political sitcom The Thick of It rather than real-life political narrative.

Never to be outdone, the Abkhazians raised quite a ruckus: appalled at the removal of the memorial, they launched an online petition (with direct involvement of their so-called government, no less) to put it back. At the same time, an international group of experts and researchers of the South Caucasus condemned the removal, issuing a joint statement in which they warned against politicizing the matter. “Fragile trust,” the statement intoned, “is easily broken.” Moreover, while the war of words was being waged, in came a statement from the East Ayrshire council that took things to new, dizzying heights of absurdity. It turns out that the removal of the memorial was never on the cards in the first place, and the council had merely had the memorial assessed by a professional stonemason. Blissfully unaware of political sensitivities in the distant lands of the South Caucasus, the council contractor removed the memorial to a stonemason’s yard on a temporary basis for assessment. The bizarre saga served yet another reminder of the ever-deepening rift between Abkhazian and Georgian communities, something that the joint statement above was so keen to underline. Among its signatories was none other than Bruno Coppieters, one of the most well-respected authors and celebrated scholars of South Caucasus conflicts, who was kind enough to discuss the matter at length with GEORGIA TODAY and Panorama TV Show.

“Whilst the legacy of wars is inherently political, politicizing war memorials does nothing to address the causes of violent conflict or to further the cause of reconciliation…” said the statement from the experts.

The age-old question, though: who did it first? The fact that it was the Abkhazians who put a flag on the memorial, thus sending a political message, seems to have somehow escaped the attention of the esteemed community that penned the statement. When pressed about the matter, Coppieters says their main gripe was against the negative consequences of removing a war memorial without prior consultation with all those who have a strong emotional connection to it.

“The memorial was there for 20 years without anyone taking much notice. As a result of the Georgian attempt to have the Abkhaz flag removed, the Abkhaz authorities said: ‘We are the victims here. We’re suffering, and the Abkhaz side is not being respected’. It’s clear that unilateral acts directed at weakening the other side can have negative consequences. If there is something that needs to be changed then all parties should agree to the changes.”

The consensus, however, has proven evasive so far. The Georgian side, in its quest to confine the so-called Abkhazian state to the lowest depths of the political world, is unlikely to accept any statehood symbols but that of their own, while Abkhazians are equally adamant on the issue. The solution, for Coppieters, might lie in the creation of a new war memorial that would be acceptable to both sides. Such negotiations would be difficult, of course: “It is something to be achieved in the longer-term,” he says, “and in the meantime, existing war memorials such as the one in Kilmarnock should be left as they are. I think there is too much fear in Georgia about the idea of creeping recognition. It’s obvious that a general recognition of Abkhazia as an independent state is not going to happen anyway.”

Fear, however, was not the only sentiment in Georgian society after the news about the memorial broke. Anger, for one, was much more prevalent. True to Coppieters prediction, all things negative poured from those who commented on the issue; neither reconciliation nor finding common ground were on the cards. Abkhazians weren’t the only ones Georgians were upset with – the British took stick too. How would they like it, one particularly inquisitive commenter asked, if we were to build a war memorial dedicated to the victims of the Falkland’s conflict and slap an Argentine flag on it?

“I think fear is a terrible guide for creating new solutions,” was Coppieters’ sage advice. “And anger’s not much better either, if not worse. The real question here is whether the removal of a symbol on a memorial brings us closer to reconciliation. My answer is, not at all. One side is venting its anger, claiming an imaginary victory; the other side states that it is a victim once again. It’s simply not constructive.”

Beyond the official narrative, the main thesis of Georgia’s staunch non-recognition policy rests on not allowing the Abkhazian state to get even a glimpse of international attention. When asked how successful that policy might be, Coppieters speaks of coins and their double sides.

“As regards non-recognition, it’s a successful one. Abkhazia is indeed isolated on the diplomatic level, recognized by very few governments around the globe. But then again, there’s an agreement that the non-recognition policy should be coupled with an active engagement policy. And it’s exactly that twin of the two that is doing rather poorly. Engagement, regaining the trust of communities, is the key to long-term unification.”

Coppieters was among the third-party people who tried to take an initiative to bring the fractured communities closer together. He says the degree of distrust between sides poses an insurmountable obstacle towards any initiative that is taken. Reminiscing, he talks about his own idea of establishing links between universities in Abkhazia and the EU which would on the long-term allow young Abkhazians to meet Georgian students and students from other countries. Instead of having the only option of going to study in Russia, Abkhazians would have alternative options. The Erasmus program, he says, served as an inspiration. But an inspiration was all it ended up being as both Georgia and Abkhazia found it difficult to find enough trust between them to get it going: neither side was willing to make concessions. The Georgian authorities, in particular, seemed to be fearful that there might come too much closeness with EU universities and their Abkhaz counterparts. Professors from the EU were teaching a few courses in Abkhazia, but the project didn’t go beyond its pilot phase, something Coppieters regrets to this day.

“We have leaders around Europe who are the product of Erasmus. Why not make creative moves in order to have Abkhaz university students participating?” he asks. “This is possible even without diplomatic recognition. Taiwan is not recognized by any EU member state, but they participate in the Erasmus program. I’m under the impression that when the Georgian authorities talk about engagement, they remain too fearful of criticism by the domestic opposition. Yet taking risks is necessary. Of course, then you will have Abkhaz students in European universities defending points of view which the Georgian authorities would not agree with, but that’s part of freedom of expression. In the long-term, it brings people together.”

The Erasmus program, together with the riches and possibilities that the AA and DCFTA agreements have to offer, is among the diplomatic leverage that Georgia tries to use to make itself more attractive for Abkhazians. But such proposals should not be made with the main purpose of making the welfare of the Abkhaz population dependent on decisions in Tbilisi. Coppieters thinks that such an attempt would be counterproductive. “That’s not how people come together. Equality is needed,” he says, “to achieve trust and reconciliation.”

“The very idea that Georgia will become attractive to Abkhazians, that one particularly sunny day Abkhazians will switch sides because the Georgian population has more welfare and more benefits to offer, is not a strategy that will work.”

As he so effortlessly steamrolls over the policy that the authorities in Tbilisi have been selling their voters for the last 10 years, Coppieters reveals his own insight on the solutions that would, in the long-term, make re-unification a realistic prospect. Being a federalist, he thinks that, “under the right circumstances,” the federal model might be the key. And not the federalism of the Russian ilk, where the regions are subject to central authority, but a “more democratic one, where the federal authorities and the federated states are equally subject to the Constitution and the rule of law”.

“Nationalist movements in South Ossetia, Abkhazia and Georgia have traditionally defended different objectives. However, multinational federations should be able to address such conflicting issues. In Belgium or Spain, you also have several nations that have very different identities. And it is all about equality among nations in creating plurinational statehood.”

Be that as it may, there is still a gigantic elephant lurking in the dark room of South Caucasus politics. Or, rather, a bear, to be more stereotypically correct. The factor of Russia cannot be underestimated and it has frequently popped up when discussing that particular federal model Coppieters seems so keen on. With a hierarchy among nations out of the equation, one of the main problems is the creation of a federal state structure that is able to make coherent decisions in the field of foreign policy. In such a situation, Russia risks playing the tune through an Abkhazian flute. This means that effective decision-making structures have to be created which minimalize the negative impact of external intervention. A second problem to be addressed is the relations between national communities in Abkhazia itself. “The tensions among them were a root cause of the Georgian-Abkhaz war and have to be taken into account in designing Abkhaz state institutions,” he says. “This is no less important, and complicated, than designing the relationship between Abkhazia and Georgia within a common federal framework.”

As we take a light step into the dreaded realm of geopolitical speculation, by his judgment, any kind of agreement between Georgia and Abkhazia would have to give the Kremlin some degree of control over the security situation. The Abkhaz side will need a guarantor, and this cannot be NATO. This is one of the concessions Georgia would have to accept, and NATO as well, in order to achieve a settlement. “This may create strong fears in Georgia, and this is one of the reasons I don’t see such negotiations happening anytime soon. However, you need a long-term perspective about solutions on reunification. Difficult negotiations will have to take place and Russia will undoubtedly play its part in that context.”

Author: Vazha Tavberidze

Source: Georgia Today
Other Stories
First Georgian Harvard graduate introduces his software evaluating humans
Tech pioneer Archil Cheishvili was the first Georgian who studied at Harvard University. He is the CEO and co-founder of the successful software company Palatine Analytics that analyzes people with the help of artificial intelligence.
The New York Times on establishing the internet in Tusheti, Georgia’s remote highland
World’s leading newspaper, The New York Times devotes an article to installing internet in Tusheti,
Cancer Control Measures: Raising Awareness in Georgia
In Georgia, about 10,000 new cases of tumor are observed annually. Over the last three years, tumor cases have increased by 36-37%.
Attracting More Tourists to Tusheti's Mountainous Villages
For the first time ever, I found myself in Tusheti in 2001,
Traditional Alilo march to be held on January 7
The traditional Alilo march will be held in relation to the Christmas feast on January 7.
How a Georgian Artist’s Painting Ended up in Björk’s Hands
Legendary Icelandic musician and singer Björk paid a visit to Georgia
Queen Elizabeth congratulates Patriarch of Georgia on the 40th anniversary of his enthronement
Elizabeth ll, the Queen of the United Kingdom, has congratulated to Ilia II, Catholicos-Patriarch of All Georgia, on his 40th anniversary
Lady Gaga wearing red dress by famous Georgian designer
Georgian fashion industry captured the attention by world media.
11 Georgian films kept in Cinematheque of Russian Federation transported to Georgia
"The process of bringing Georgian cinematographic heritage to its motherland continues
Georgia’s main Christmas tree has been festively lit up in Tbilisi
Georgia’s main Christmas tree was festively brightened on December 15
Special New Year discounts at Diplomatic Duty Free Shop
Diplomatic Duty Free Shop located in the heart of Georgia's capital, Tbilisi, makes its customers happy for Christmas
Eco-friendly marathon has begun
Environment protection is one of the most essential problems nowadays
La Boheme hosts Tbilisi International Women’s Association event
Tbilisi International Women’s Association event took place at Tbilisi’s newly opened cozy place La Boheme on December 6.
Tbilisi to see eco-friendly new buses
Tbilisi City Hall has declared that it is interested in purchasing new eco-friendly buses for Georgia’s capital Tbilisi.
Meet 20-year-old Georgian student who will work at Facebook headquarters
20-year-old Luka Lomtadze will join the world's most popular social network Facebook team from this May.
Tbilisi main Christmas tree to be lit on December 15
The main Christmas tree of Georgia’s capital Tbilisi will be lit at 20:00 on December 15,
Ex-President of Georgia Mikheil Saakashvili arrested in Kiev again
Mikheil Saakashvili, the former president of Georgia, was arrested on Friday in Ukraine
Georgian student recruited as an intern at Facebook’s head office
The Facebook Company has chosen a student from Georgia, Luka Lomadze, out of 250,000 applicants
Georgia’s Constitutional Court decriminalizes regular use of cannabis
Under the decision of Georgia’s Constitutional Court, the use of cannabis has been decriminalized.
Average temperature in Georgia to be 10 degrees warmer than norm
The average air temperature will be close or a bit above the norm in winter,
Tbilisi’s famous monuments appear in masks - Anti-pollution campaign in the city
Tbilisi city became a witness of a quite strange act.
 “This as a big tragedy” - Patriarch of All Georgia delivers service for the victims in Batumi
All Georgia received this as a big tragedy, - Catholicos Patriarch of All Georgia, His Holiness and Beatitude Ilia II said at the Leogrand hotel in Batumi,
Patriarch to deliver service for fire victims
The Catholicos-Patriarch of Georgia Ilia II will hold a service for the victims of fire
Investigation is underway into violation of fire safety norms at Leogrand hotel
The investigation should be very objective and very fast,
Fire in Batumi’s hotel claims lives of 11 people
At least 11 people died and a dozen were injured on Friday
GEL Exchange Rate
Other Stories
Photographer Daro Sulakauri has recently published a photo project on the villages bordering the breakaway regions of South Ossetia (Tskhinvali Region) and Abkhazia.
Like many Eastern European countries, Georgia started the celebrations for Christmas Eve during the night of the 6th of January.
Christmas has always been a special celebration in Georgia.
It happened practically overnight: Tbilisi has dressed up for Christmas.
The 21-year-old Georgian singer Natia Todua is the new “Voice of Germany”.
World-renowned Georgian pianist Khatia Buniatishvili has again been spotlighted together with popular actor Orlando Bloom.
When walking around Tbilisi, capital of Georgia, apart from picturesque views, one might witness an unusual scene.
21-year-old Natia Todua's performance in German New Voice captivated judges and the whole Georgia.
The Huffington Post, popular American news and opinion website, publishes an interview with young Georgian entrepreneurs
Georgian Wine Festival is yet another surprise for wine enthusiasts,especially Georgian wine lovers that one should not miss.
GEL Exchange
January 2018
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31