Overt & Covert Dangers of the 1920 Russian-Georgian Treaty
07 October, 2010
Overt & Covert Dangers of the 1920 Russian-Georgian Treaty

Based on that Agreement, Zhordania demanded of France and England to leave the Batumi Port. Their leaving Georgia was an absolute catastrophe for the country. Georgia was left alone in confrontation with Russia. Professor Simon Maskharashvili has more.
GJ – In the duration of the three-year history of the Georgian Democratic Republic, the Georgian military units had rebuffed the Russian aggression many times. In 1920, Georgia had a very realistic chance of liberating the entire South Caucasus from the Russian

violence, but Noah Zhordania made a flagrantly unlikely decision of stopping the fight of Georgian troops against the Russian Bolshevik forces, having ordered them to retreat. I would like to hear more comment on this. 
SM – Not only he did stop the military action of his troops, he also continued acting behind the back of the Georgian army: he commissioned the most untalented among the Georgian diplomats Grigol Uratadze, who was Georgia’s ambassador to Russia at that time, to conduct diplomatic negotiations with Lenin.
GJ –What did he want to negotiate with Russia? 
SM – The end of war! What else?
GJ – Isn’t it a paradox that a winning party ask for negotiating the end of war? 
SM – On the 7th of May, Uratadze (he was hurriedly made Georgia’s foreign minister) and Karakhan - the deputy to the Russian foreign minister Chicherin signed the Russian-Georgian Treaty in Moscow.
GJ – What did the Treaty envisage?
SM – That was a disastrous document for Georgia. In compliance with the Treaty, Russia recognized Georgia’s territorial integrity. Also, Russia considered the lands, which are today within the boundaries of Armenia and Azerbaijan, as integral part of Georgia (incidentally, the-then recognized Georgian territory was 50 % bigger than what it is today). At the same time, Georgia was being declared a neutral state, with Russia as a guarantor of its neutrality. As you might remember, the Bolshevik Russia had recognized the independence of Georgia as early as 1918 in compliance with the treaty, signed by Russia with Germany. Although the Treaty lost its power on part of Germany for the reasons mentioned before, the Bolshevik Russia continued to be the Bolshevik Russia! There was no need at all for us to have been recognized by Russia all over again in 1920. This statement makes sense because Russia itself was not yet recognized by the West. The mentioned Russian-Georgian Treaty also stipulated that Georgia would not allow the bourgeois military units on its territory.     
GJ – What did that mean specifically? 
SM – Based on that Treaty, Noah Zhordania demanded of France and England to leave the Batumi port.
GJ – Were the French and English military units stationed in Batumi?
SM – Yes, they were. They had a military base in Batumi. Their leaving Georgia was an inevitable fiasco for Georgia. 
GJ – That would have left Georgia confronted with Russia all by itself, wouldn’t it? 
SM – Sure! One-on-one! On top of everything else, the Treaty was allowing the legal existence and activity of the Communist Party in Georgia. Also, a 500-strong Russian embassy was planned to open in Tbilisi, the majority of which were supposed to be former Bolshevik saboteurs. Politically speaking, it was a diplomatic corps, but in reality it was a group of 500 terrorists sent over to work on the downfall of Georgia, endorsed by Zhordania himself. Communists Philip Makharadze and Sasha Gegechkori strutted in the streets of Tbilisi with diplomatic passports in their pockets. They learnt the local situation, doing their subversive job and building up the project of opening the way for the Russian occupational troops into Tbilisi.
GJ – Were any Georgians among the Russian embassy staff?
SM – Yes, there were. Georgians made up a considerable part of the Russian embassy, but they were traitors. The Treaty was not yet enforced when Zhordania organized a major assembly of the Second International (an organization of socialist and labor parties) in Tbilisi with the participation of Marxists, Socialists and revolutionaries, among them Messrs. McDonalds and Kautski – absolutely unacceptable folks for the British government. Such were the mistakes made by the Zhordania government: he made no efforts to drive the Russians out of the South Caucasus; he secretly signed with Russians the disastrous for the nation Treaty, declaring the Georgian state and its army neutral; he turned Georgia into a haven for socialists and communists; he forced the French and English military units and fleet to withdraw from Georgia.   
GJ – What do you think, was all that being done deliberately or was the result of lack of experience. 
SM – It is hardly imaginable that a government of any nation could be that ignorant . . . Let us not impose the answer on our readers and give them a chance to make their own educated conclusions. Unfortunately, we have had no access so far to classified and undisclosed state archives of the Russian president. We are not certain about genuine relations between the Georgian leader of that time Noah Zhordania and the head of Russian Bolsheviks Lenin. (Presumably, they were good enough). It is also strange that the signatory of the Russian-Georgian Treaty Uratadze is not noticeable anywhere before and after as a state figure and person.    
GJ – Would this mean that he did his job and then disappeared? 
SM – Most probably, yes! It is a fact though that he was not a political figure, but he had good relations with the Russian Bolsheviks. Judging by the results of his activity, this constituted treason of national interests of Georgia. On the other hand, as I said, there will be no certainty whether it was a simple narrow-mindedness or treason until the Russian presidential archives are disclosed.

Print
Other Stories
Israeli Embassy addresses Georgian citizens, who intend to attend Holy Fire Ceremony
The Embassy of Israel to Georgia has released a statement addressing the citizens of Georgia, who intend to attend the celebration of the Holy Fire in Jerusalem.
Georgian Minister, who could have started a Nuclear War
An involuntary soviet officer, who could have plunged Turkey into the “nuclear winter”,
The Guardian: How Jack Shepherd tried to elude British justice in Tbilisi
The Guardian has recently published an article about Jack Shepherd “How Jack Shepherd tried to elude British justice in Tbilisi”.
Photography Workshop with Karolina Jonderko
Karolina is an award-winning photographer with a master's degree in photography from the Polish National Film,
Jennifer Lopez wearing David Koma in her New Music Video
A new song “Medicine” by American singer Jennifer Lopez featuring Moroccan-American rapper French Montana has just released.
Lithuanian Embassy releases statement regarding April 9 tragedy
The Embassy of Lithuania to Georgia has released a statement regarding April 9 tragedy in Georgia.
6 streets in Tbilisi to be named after April 9 female victims
Six streets in Tbilisi will be named after female victims of April 1989 tragedy.
Exclusive interview with Erik Høeg, Head of EUMM Georgia
Georgian Journal offers its readers an exclusive interview with Erik Høeg, Head of Mission of the EU Monitoring Mission (EUMM) Georgia.
30 years since April 9 tragedy
30 years have passed since 9 April 1989.
Georgian actress Vika Kalandia on the set of a new TV show by Netflix
Georgian actress Vika Kalandia has recently published photos
Georgian actress Vika Kalandia to appear in a new TV show by Netflix
Georgian actress Vika Kalandia will appear in a new TV show on Netflix.
Remains of Georgian soldiers identified in Holland
The remains of Georgian soldiers killed on Texel Island, Leusden were identified using DNA analysis in Holland.
Georgian Inventor students will travel to NASA Space Center
The winner of the Millennium Innovation Competition has been revealed.
Lady Gaga chooses Georgian designer Tamuna Ingorokva
Tamuna Ingorokva is a successful Georgian designer.
Gifted teacher Lado Apkhazava warmly welcomed back in Georgia
Lado Apkhazava is a Georgian teacher who is among 10 finalists of the Global Teacher Prize 2019.
 Georgian TV presenter, who has traveled to 112 countries and 5 continents
We are sitting by the fire and the chief tells me: You behave as if you were one of us;
Malkhaz Kobauri sentenced to life imprisonment for killing the Smiths family
Malkhaz Kobauri, the shepherd accused of murdering three members of the Smiths family in Khada Gorge, has been sentenced to life imprisonment.
Georgia gave the world wine – what did Jeremy Clarkson find amazing in Georgia?
Last autumn The Grand Tour team Jeremy Clarkson, James May and Richard Hammond visited Georgia and recorded one of the episodes here.
Jury find shepherd, accused of killing American family, guilty
A jury has found Malkhaz Kobauri, the shepherd who is accused of killing American family
The Grand Tour team, Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond, James May visit Georgia's occupied territories
A new video featuring The Grand Tour’s trip to Georgia has recently appeared on the internet.
Ukraine and Georgia fighting for the common occupant
Georgian brand Giovanni Morra issues anti-occupational passport holder for Ukraine.
Bidzina Ivanishvili’s youngest son Tsotne Ivanishvili
Tsotne Ivanishvili is the youngest son of Bidzina Ivanishvili, the former Prime Minister of Georgia.
Man fights wolf, saves life of two women in Georgia
Yesterday night in Georgia, Tsalka municipality a wolf attacked three people. Fortunately, all of them are alive.
5 Georgian Women’s Successful Career Abroad
On March 8, the world celebrates international women’s day.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
GEL Exchange Rate
Convertor
20.04.2019
21.04.2019
USD
1
USD
2.6935
2.6935
EUR
1
EUR
3.0291
3.0291
GBP
1
GBP
3.5021
3.5021
RUB
100
RUB
4.2126
4.2126
Other Stories
World famous British singer Jessie J has decided to wear clothes made by Anouki Areshidze, Georgian designer and wife of the mayor of Tbilisi.
Bassiani, one of the most popular underground clubs not only in Georgia but throughout Europe as well, has opened today
An amazing video made in Georgia by tourists from the Philippines have gone viral on the internet.
Over the recent two days May 12-13 Tbilisi city saw a peaceful protest rally in the center of the city.
Hundreds of people took to the main street Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi to protest the raid in Tbilisi’s popular night clubs.
Two bear cubs listed as endangered on the red list were handed over to Tbilisi Zoo,
Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze and Deputy Tbilisi Mayor Ms. Sophio Khuntsaria have gifted a food stand
Pamela Anderson, famous Canadian American actress and model has appeared in the chic sunglasses by internationally acclaimed Georgian designer George Keburia.
A ski lift accident in Georgia’s eastern Gudauri resort,in particular at Sadzele 5 lift, has left 8 people with injuries.
The ski lift in Gudauri winter resort in Georgia has broke down in the aftermath of which several people have been injured.
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.6935
EUR
1
EUR
3.0291
GBP
1
GBP
3.5021
RUB
100
RUB
4.2126
April 2019
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30